The origins of gender differences in competitiveness and earnings expectations
How to cite
Kosse, Fabian. 2022. "The origins of gender differences in competitiveness and earnings expectations." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008935. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8935-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We aim to explore whether and how the social environment at a young age differentially influences the willingness to compete of girls and boys as well as their earnings expectations. In a sample of German adolescents, we first investigate how the competitive preferences of girls and boys vary with socioeconomic status (SES) and the preferences of their mothers. To elicit the competitiveness of the children and their mothers, we use a novel easy-to-use and validated measure developed by Buser et al. (2021). We then analyze the causal impact of a change to the social environment. More specifically, we examine whether giving low-SES children randomized access to a well-established and intensive mentoring program has an impact on individual willingness to compete as well as earnings expectations. For a period of about one year, treated children are provided with a mentor whose brief is to act as a role model and to enrich the social environment of the child. Volunteer mentors are predominantly university students and all girls receive a female mentor, thereby exposing low-SES girls to a successful female role model. Role models have been shown to be influential for the choices of young women, for example, in the context of education (Carlana, 2019; Porter and Serra, 2020; Breda et al., 2020). We therefore expect a positive impact of the mentoring intervention on the willingness to compete of low-SES girls, potentially resulting in a reduction in the gender gap. Moreover, there is mounting evidence that individual preferences for competition predict labor market outcomes (Reuben et al., 2015; Buser et al., 2021). Therefore, about six years after the end of the intervention, we administered a questionnaire in which we elicit adolescents' beliefs about their likely earnings at age 30.
Intervention
The intervention is a well-established non-profit mentoring program called “Balu und Du” (Baloo and You). In this program, elementary school children are provided with a mentor for the duration of one year. The mentors, called Baloos, are mostly female university students (aged from 18 to 30) who voluntarily care for their mentees, called Mowglis. All girls in our sample received a female mentor, while a minority of boys had a male mentor. The mentors act as role models and “benevolent friends” who encourage the acquisition of new ideas and skills by enriching the social environment of the children (Müller-Kohlenberg and Drexler, 2013). On a practical level, a mentored child typically spends one afternoon per week in one-to-one interaction with his/her mentor. During this time, the mentor and the mentee engage in joint activities, which are adapted to the individual needs, strengths, and interests of the child (and mentor). To date, the Balu und Du mentoring program has arranged and supervised around 13,000 mentor-child relationships in more than 50 different locations in Germany.
Most mentors are female and all girls in our sample receive a female mentor, thereby providing low-SES girls with a female role model. Role models have been shown to influence the choices of young women, for example, in the context of education (Carlana, 2019; Porter and Serra, 2020; Breda et al., 2020). Most mentors are university students and past studies have also shown that both female and male university students and graduates are typically more willing to compete compared to the rest of the population (see, for example, Buser et al., 2021).
Experimental design
We recruited participants and their parents from the two cities Cologne and Bonn in Germany. In 2011, we invited all families living in those cities with children born between September 2003 and August 2004 to participate in a mentoring program, as well as one third of families with children born between September 2002 and August 2003 (N=14,451). We truthfully informed parents that, due to capacity constraints, participation in the program was not guaranteed. 1626 families indicated a willingness to participate and answered a short questionnaire including questions on income, education and whether both parents lived in the same household. We focus on those children whose parents met at least one of the following three criteria: (i) Equivalence income of the household is lower than 1065 Euro, corresponding to the 30th percentile of the German income distribution. (ii) Neither parent has a school-leaving degree qualifying for university studies. (iii) Parents do not live in the same household. We invited these children (N=700) and their parents for a baseline interview conducted in September to October 2011. 590 children and their parents participated in the baseline interview and gave their written consent to allow the transmission of their address to the organization running the mentoring program. This is our main sample. Out of this sample, 212 families were randomly selected to be treated (“treatment group”), the remaining 378 families form the control group.
We also recruited a high socio-economic status (SES) comparison group from the children whose parents did not meet either of the three criteria listed above (N=150 invited, N=122 participated in the baseline interview and gave written consent).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.