Memory, Trauma and Economic Behavior Among Refugees: Experimental Evidence from Teaching “Positive Visualization” in Ethiopia

How to cite

Meyer, Christian Johannes; Bryan, Gharad; Delfino, Alexia; Worku, Benyam; Pople, Ashley. 2022. "Memory, Trauma and Economic Behavior Among Refugees: Experimental Evidence from Teaching “Positive Visualization” in Ethiopia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008934. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8934-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Christian Johannes Meyer* , Gharad Bryan , Alexia Delfino , Benyam Worku , Ashley Pople

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008934
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8934-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-02-04 – 2022-12-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, D01, D83, D90, D91, I12
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8934

Abstract

The economic inclusion of refugees is a challenge for host economy governments and development partners. While there is evidence that poor mental health can hold back the economic inclusion of refugees, little is known about potential low-cost and scalable interventions to overcome such ‘internal’ constraints, such as the effects of trauma on the ability to imagine the present or future. In this project, we use a survey among refugees in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, and a randomized trial of a high-intensity psychological program on “positive visualization” to study the role of these constraints. We hypothesize that learning to vividly and precisely imagine a positive present or future and to contrast negative memories from past traumatic experiences can help refugees take steps towards improving their economic livelihoods in the host economy. To shed light on mechanisms, we use a cross-randomized priming intervention and hypothesize that “positive visualization” improves the economic choices of participants by reducing their perceived background risk of daily economic choices.

Intervention

Our main intervention consists of four weekly sessions of training in positive visualization. Each session is conducted one-on-one by a trainer with one participant and lasts about an hour. The intervention follows a predefined script, but also allows for individual reflections of participants with the trainer.

To shed light on the mechanism through which the treatment affects outcomes for participants, we cross-randomize a trauma priming intervention that has been used in the literature in psychology and economics. We adapt Callen et al.’s (2014) protocol to administer two primes just before asking subjects to make a risky investment choice. We ask one half of respondents: “We are interested in understanding your daily experiences that make you happy or joyous. This could be anything, for example birth of child, marriage of a relative, or success in your job. Could you describe an event in the past year that caused you happiness? (POSITIVE) and the other half of respondents a negative analogue (NEGATIVE): ““We are interested in understanding your daily experiences that may make you fearful or anxious. This could be anything, for example getting sick, experiencing violence, losing a job, etc. Could you describe one event in the past year that caused you fear or anxiety?”. The priming will be conducted at baseline and endline.

Experimental design

We conduct a field experiment that randomly varies treatments along two dimensions: (1) whether or not participants are offered to participate in the positive visualization sessions; and (2) whether participants are exposed to a positive or a negative priming intervention. The priming intervention is used at the baseline survey and repeated at the midline survey. We cross-randomize individuals into the positive or negative priming in the baseline and midline surveys. Randomization is stratified on gender.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization performed in the back office in Stata.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
No clusters
Observations
1800 individuals
Arms
Positive visualization treatment: 900 individuals (of which 450 in positive priming and 450 in negative priming) Control: 900 individuals (of which 450 in positive priming and 450 in negative priming)
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcomes belong to three families: 1) Risk taking 1a) An unincentivized survey item adapted from the Global Preference Survey (Falk et al., 2018). 1b) An incentivized measure of risk aversion using the Gneezy-Potters-Charness investment task (Gneezy and Potters 1997, Charness and Gneezy 2010) 2) Memory recall 2a) Adapted versions of the autobiographical memory test (AMT, see Griffith et al., 2009), backward oriented, adapted to the Ethiopian context. For 5 different scenarios, we ask respondents to describe a specific memory that the scenario reminds them of. This question allows us to characterize a participant’s “memory database”, to link it to their economic behavior and to understand the effect of the intervention on it. 3) Future Visualization 3a) Adapted versions of the autobiographical memory test (AMT, see Griffith et al., 2009), future oriented, adapted to the Ethiopian context. For 5 different scenarios, we ask respondents to imagine a specific future event that is linked to the given scenario. This question allows us to characterize how the training changes future visualization by the participants.
Secondary outcomes
We classify the secondary outcomes in four families: 1) Employment outcomes: Job search, engagement in employment and/or self-employment 2) Income, consumption, and welfare: earnings, savings, consumption 3) Mental and physical health 3a) Cantril Ladder Life Satisfaction 3b) WHODAS Functioning Scale To study the mechanisms of the intervention, we also measure: 1) Self-efficacy (from a 6-items Self Efficacy Scale) 2) Expectations of employment, earnings and movement conditional on receiving with a certain probability a permit to work in Ethiopia 3) Reservation wage 4) Reaction to negative and positive priming
Sponsors
Name: UK Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office / United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees / World Bank “Building the Evidence on Forced Displacement Program” Location: Washington, DC Url: https://www.worldbank.org/en/programs/building-the-evidence-on-forced-displacement Name: Netherlands’ Ministry of Foreign Affairs Prospects Partnership Location: The Hague. Netherlands Url: https://www.government.nl/topics/development-cooperation/the-development-policy-of-the-netherlands/refugees-and-migration
Partners
Name: Ethiopian Refugee and Returnees Service (RRS) Partner_type: government Url: https://twitter.com/ethrefugee

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords