Does perceived labor-market competition increase out-group discrimination between refugees and hosts? Evidence from Uganda and Ethiopia.

How to cite

Kebede, Tewodros; Bousquet, Julie; Gasten, Anna; Kadigo, Mark Marvin; Maystadt, Jean-François; Salemi, Colette; Stave, Svein Erik. 2022. "Does perceived labor-market competition increase out-group discrimination between refugees and hosts? Evidence from Uganda and Ethiopia.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008912. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8912-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Tewodros Kebede* , Julie Bousquet , Anna Gasten , Mark Marvin Kadigo , Jean-François Maystadt , Colette Salemi , Svein Erik Stave

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008912
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8912-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-01-29 – 2022-07-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J6, C93, D91, O15, J01
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8912

Abstract

Labor market integration of refugees, a critical step towards their self-reliance and local integration, can be impeded by local perceptions of labor market competition in an environment where job opportunities are limited. This, in addition to anti-refugee rhetoric stressing rivalry over job opportunities, may contribute to resentments, mistrust, and discrimination between refugees and hosts. To date, it is unclear whether perceptions of labor market competition between refugees and hosts compromise community-building efforts across the two groups. Our study seeks to evaluate whether perceptions of labor market competition negatively influence out-group attitudes. We use a randomized questionnaire module that exposes the survey respondents to narratives about the out-group, stressing either differences or commonalities in the labor market characteristics between the respondent and a fictitious in-group or out-group individual.

Intervention

Our study consists of a randomized questionnaire module that will be implemented as part of a large labor-market-related survey.
We are targeting refugee populations and host community members living in close proximity in rural and urban settings in Uganda and Ethiopia.

Our survey sample will cover approximately
2400 refugees and 2400 hosts across rural and urban areas of Uganda
2400 refugees and 2400 hosts across rural and urban areas of Ethiopia

As part of this survey, respondents will be randomly exposed to different narratives about a fictitious member of the out-group or in-group with identical or different labor characteristics.
Some respondents of the local host group will thus listen to a narrative about a fictitious individual of the host population and others to a narrative about a refugee. The same applies to respondents of the group of refugees. This fictitious character’s labor market characteristics, such as their occupation, are included in the vignette read to the respondent. Our experiment randomly varies this information across vignettes so that it either matches or is different from the respondent’s own job characteristics.
The study aims to analyze the interplay between perceived labor market competition and out-group discrimination. Using the results of our experiment, we will evaluate prevailing attitudes regarding out-group discrimination among hosts and refugees in Ethiopia and Uganda. Moreover, we will ask whether perceived labor market competition is an important driver of discriminatory attitudes towards the out-group.

Because the experiment is being executed in Uganda and Ethiopia, we can additionally compare the results from the two countries to descriptively analyze whether differential migration policies correlate with perceived labor market competition and discriminatory responses. In an attempt to capture additional effects and take advantage of using two identical designs in two countries sharing similar characteristics, we aim at doing a cross-country analysis, pooling the two sets of data together and measuring the same outcomes. Particular attention will be put on the use of sampling weights.
The intervention is planned to start on 29 January 2022 in Uganda and 20 February 2022 in Ethiopia and end on 28 February 2022 and 15 March 2022 in Uganda and Ethiopia, respectively.

Experimental design

Our experimental intervention is embedded in a survey questionnaire focused on labor market outcomes and interaction between refugees and host communities in Uganda and Ethiopia.

As part of this experiment, respondents are randomly assigned to four equally sized treatment groups. Each respondent will listen to a single narrative about a fictitious individual who is either from the in-group or the out-group and either sharing or not the respondent’s labor market characteristics.
T1: In-group; same labor market characteristics (25%)
T2: In-group; different labor market characteristics (25%)
T3: Out-group; same labor market characteristics (25%)
T4: Out-group; different labor market characteristics (25%)

Due to the matching process along with labor market characteristics, only those respondents who indicate being currently employed (including self-employed) or actively searching for work will administer the experimental module.

After the narrative is read out loud to the respondents, they are asked to respond to questions about the fictitious individual, notably concerning perceived labor market competition and general attitudes (prejudice, discrimination).
The purpose of our study is to better understand discriminatory attitudes towards the out- and in-group, and to gauge the extent to which negative/positive perceptions of refugees among host communities as well as obstacles/drivers to integration among refugees are driven by the perception that both groups are competing or not in the labor market.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer-based
Randomization unit
Individual. We stratify by refugee status (refugee or non-refugee), and location (Uganda: Kampala, Isingiro District; Ethiopia: Addis Ababa, Somali Region).
Clusters
210 Clusters in Uganda (Enumeration areas from the Census of 2014 in Uganda) 210 Clusters in Ethiopia (Enumeration areas from a mapping planned for the upcoming Census)
Observations
Uganda: Isingiro District: 1200 Ugandan households and 1200 Refugee households Kampala District: 1200 Ugandan households and 1200 Refugee households Ethiopia: Addis Ababa region: 1200 Ethiopian households and 1200 Refugee households Somali region: 1200 Ethiopian households and 1200 Refugee households Note that we are expecting a certain attrition and non-response rate given the refugee-host context in both countries. We expect attrition to be at random, proportionally distributed across treatment groups. Another correction we will make to our sample for relevance is that we are administering the experiment exclusively to individuals who are currently working (employed, self-employed) or unemployed individuals actively looking for a job. That way, we are excluding out of the labor force individuals, who would struggle to relate to the narrative. Consequently, our sample size is likely to reduce, especially among the refugee population who is more likely to be out of the labor force. However, since randomization is stratified based on groups (refugees/hosts) and location (rural/urban), we expect this to be proportional across our four treatment groups. Besides testing our four hypotheses on the entire sample (refugees and hosts in urban and rural areas of Ethiopia and Uganda), we may do some heterogeneous analyses. Therefore we will divide the sample according to these characteristics to disentangle further between groups’ differences in attitudes. The experimental module is part of a large survey executed in the areas of interest. It consists of a household survey where all the members are asked a set of questions related to their socio-economic conditions. This survey lasts about 20 minutes and aims at drawing an extensive picture of the types of households we are interviewing. The household survey is followed by an RSI (Random Sample Individual) survey where one working-age individual is selected at random among all household members. The survey lasts one hour and extensively goes over the labor market history of the respondent. It also includes our experiment and sections related to integration, perception, and networks. Thus, our experiment is administered to one individual per household. Consequently, we do not have to cluster our standard errors at the household level and we are avoiding spillover effects.
Arms
The whole sample is split into 4 treatment arms. When disregarding attrition, non-response, and out-of-the-labor-force individuals by whom the experiment will not be administered, we are left with 2,400 respondents per treatment arm.
Primary outcomes
Our primary measures of interest are; (1) Measures of discrimination towards the fictitious individual (2) Measures of perceived labor market competition and labor market discrimination

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords