Justice Study
How to cite
Marechal, Michel; Beerli, Andreas; Greiner, James; Langer, Julian; Faith-Slaker, April; Li, Mandy Mobley. 2022. "Justice Study." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008844. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8844-5.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Incarcerated populations have skyrocketed in most parts of the world over the past decades. How does incarceration affect people’s lives? Identifying the causal effects of incarceration has proven challenging because of the many unobservable external factors (such as pre-existing differences in personality and criminal attitudes) that threaten the validity of a comparison between incarcerated and non-incarcerated people.
We study the psychological, social, economic, and health consequences of short-term incarceration using a randomized controlled trial (RCT). We build on the US cash bail system, which in theory provides a financial incentive for court appearance but in practice may impose a high burden for subjects with lower socio-economic status. The study offers recently arrested people who were assigned bail they most likely can’t pay themselves, and who want to participate in the study, a 50-50 chance of being placed in an “Extra-Chance” group or a “Regular Pre-Trial” group. For people randomized to the Extra-Chance group, a local non-profit organization posts their bail, so that they can be free from jail while they await their trial. For people randomized to the Regular Pre-Trial group, the local non-profit does not post their bail, but participants can still achieve release if they can post their own bail, if someone else posts their bail for them, or if the judge removes their bail. In other words, people in the Regular Pre-Trial group experience the criminal justice system as though there were no study. We will use administrative data sources and administer surveys to study the impact of being released from pre-trial detention on participants' lives.
Intervention
Non-violent arrestees (i) who meet eligibility criteria and (ii) who provide informed consent will enter a lottery in which they will be randomized to either an “Extra Chance” group or a “Regular Pre-Trial" group. Two pre-existing, non-profit organizations will conduct bail fund operations using study-provided funds. The non-profits will post bail for participants randomized to the Extra Chance group. For people randomized to the Regular Pre-Trial group, the local non-profit does not post their bail, but participants may bail themselves out if they are able. Likely, many in the Regular Pre-Trial group will remain incarcerated until disposition of their cases, just as they would have been had there been no study. The local non-profits will provide assistance to link all participants to social services.
Experimental design
Eligibility and Consent:
Eligibility for the study will be determined based on two sets of criteria. The first set of criteria are meant to establish a population of participants that are non-violent and able to meaningfully participate in the study. The second set of criteria focus on restricting the population to individuals for whom bail is likely the only thing standing between them and freedom.
Once a potential participant is determined to be eligible as described above, an employee of the non-profit partners will request that county jail personnel to inform the potential participants that there is a researcher interested in speaking with them about a possible research opportunity. These staff will not explain the study or conduct any part of the recruitment or consent process. If the individuals are interested in hearing from the researcher (non-profit staff) about the research opportunity, the jail staff will escort the individual to the private space for the consent conversation.
The non-profit employee will, in a private space, describe the study to the arrestee, answer questions, and obtain written consent for study participation from the arrestee. Further, the non-profit employee will obtain signatures on forms authorizing the research team to collect administrative information from a variety of sources, such as state departments of labor and education, needed to study outcome variables. After the site-based researcher obtains consent, the participants complete a baseline survey. Subsequently, the randomization process will take place.
Randomization:
Participants will be randomized to either the Extra Chance group or the Regular Pre-Trial group with a 50-50 chance. The non-profit partners will use study-provided funds to bail out individuals randomized to the Extra Chance Group.
For people randomized to the Regular Pre-Trial group, the local non-profit does not post their bail, but participants may achieve release through otherwise available means if they are able. Likely, many in the Regular Pre-Trial group will remain incarcerated until disposition of their cases, just as they would have been had there been no study.
Outcome Data Collection:
The research team will collect outcome data from administrative data sources and surveys. The study consent form contains language to authorize the retrieval of the administrative data for a time period prior to enrollment and for a follow-up period.
The first survey will be administered at intake. Subsequently, surveys will occur according to a prespecified schedule. Surveys will continue for up to two years after randomization.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.