Applying Behavioral Science to Grant Evaluation in Local Governments
How to cite
Sasaki, Shusaku; Kuroki, Makoto. 2022. "Applying Behavioral Science to Grant Evaluation in Local Governments." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008826. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8826-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We examine how to nudge administrators in local governments to evaluate grant applications from nonprofit organizations from long-term perspectives, not short-term ones. Prior studies show that there are two effective ways for nonprofits to win grants: A) providing information about outcomes of service programs such as short-term and long-term outcomes, and B) providing information on service efforts such as accounting efficiency. However, evaluators are more likely to highly evaluate short-term outcomes than long-term outcomes because of their high time-discounting rate in behavioral economics.
We conduct a field-based survey experiment toward 1,916 local governments in Japan. We randomly divide the local governments into four groups. We set in the survey a hypothetical question, where the survey respondents are asked to evaluate the contents and quality of grant applications from two non-profit organizations: one with good short-term outcomes and the other with good long-term outcomes. The four groups consist of three treatment groups and one control group. The three treatment groups add to the latter nonprofit organization the information on A) accounting efficiency, B) social comparison nudge, and C) both. After the hypothetical question, we ask administrators in the local governments to rate the grant applications from the two nonprofit organizations and make a decision on which application is more suitable for acceptance. We also investigate whether the effects are heterogeneous by local governments’ and administrators’ characteristics.
Intervention
We randomly assign local governments to either of one control group and three treatment groups. The treatment group A provides for one nonprofit organization with good long-term outcomes the information of accounting efficiency on its service programs (accounting). The treatment group B provides the information explaining that many other local governments have already accepted similar applications which would create long-term outcomes (social comparison). The treatment group C provides both information, and the group D is the control group.
Experimental design
We randomly assign local governments to either of one control group and three treatment groups. The treatment group A provides for one nonprofit organization with good long-term outcomes the information of accounting efficiency on its service programs (accounting). The treatment group B provides the information explaining that many other local governments have already accepted similar applications which would create long-term outcomes (social comparison). The treatment group C provides both information, and the group D is the control group.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.