How does advice influence the job search behavior?
How to cite
Horvath, Gergely. 2022. "How does advice influence the job search behavior?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008809. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8809-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study involves an online lab-style experiment in which participants will solve a search task 10 times. They search for wage offers by deciding on the reservation wage (minimum acceptable offer). Then, a computer randomly draws an offer from a known wage distribution. The offer may or may not be accepted by the participant depending on the value of the offer and the reservation wage. This is repeated until the participant accepts an offer or the search round is over.
We study in this context, how individuals advise each other about the choice of reservation wage. In treatment 1, individuals participate in the 10 rounds of search, after which they leave advice to a random participant of treatment 2. The advice consists of a recommended reservation wage and a free-form text message. Participants of treatment 2 will see the advice at the beginning of the experiment and then participate in the 10 rounds of search task. The payment of the participants in treatment 1 will be influenced by the search task of the participants in treatment 2 in order to give incentives for leaving meaningful advice.
We study what sort of advice individuals leave to their peers and how that influences the peers' decisions in treatment 2. In particular, we are interested in whether receiving advice from an experienced decision-maker will improve decisions in the search task in the sense that individuals choose a reservation wage closer to the optimal value.
We will have two types of settings, one without search costs and one with search costs, in which participants receive offers only after finishing a coding task. This means we will have two versions of treatment 1 and two versions of treatment 2.
Intervention
The experiment will consist of 4 treatments, in 2 pairs. In pair 1, there will be no search costs, in pair 2, search costs are represented by a real-effort coding task. In each pair, there will be two treatments, in Treatment 1, participants complete the search task 10 times and leave advice. In Treatment 2, participants receive advice and complete the search task 10 times.
Experimental design
The main part of the experiment consists of an infinite-horizon search task, played for 10 rounds. Within a round, the following sequence of events occurs. In period 1, participants choose a reservation wage (that, is, a minimum acceptable offer), after which an offer is uniform randomly drawn from the set of integer numbers between 1 and 100 points. Participants know the offer distribution and cannot change their reservation wage after seeing their offer received. If the offer received is at least as large as the reservation wage, the participant accepts the offer and earns the value of the offer for the remaining periods of the round, without making any further
decisions. Otherwise, she moves to the next period where she chooses a reservation wage and draws an offer again, without being able to recall previous offers. In period 1 and in every subsequent period of searching, participants receive 30 points which is not paid after an offer is accepted. This process is repeated until the end of the round.
The number of periods in a round is determined randomly determined: after any given period, with 95% probability, there will be a next period, while with 5% probability, the round ends. This random termination method creates infinite horizon in the experiment.
The sum of points earned in all periods of a round constitutes the participants’ payoffs from a round. The payoffs from the whole search task are the participant’s payoffs from a randomly chosen round.
We have two versions of this search task: one as described above, another with search costs. Search costs will be implemented by a real-effort coding task. After submitting the reservation wage, participants will have to code three letters to numbers using a coding table. They will receive their offer only after finishing the coding correctly.
Both for the conditions without and with search costs, we will have two treatments. Treatment 1 consists of three parts. In Part 1,
participants complete the 10 periods of search task as described above. In Part 2, they leave advice to a randomly chosen participant of Treatment 2 suggesting a strategy to follow in the search task. The advice consists of a recommended reservation wage and a free-form text
message. Advice giving is incentivized: the advisor’s payoffs from Part 2 are equal to half of the payoffs of their advisee in the search task. In Part 3, participants fill out a survey which asks about demographic information (gender, age, education, student status), and contains a risk preference elicitation task and a cognitive reflection test, both of the latter are incentivized.
Treatment 2 consists of two parts. Part 1 contains the 10 rounds of search task. Before starting the first round, each participant in Treatment 2 receives advice from a randomly chosen participant of Treatment 1. Part 2 contains the same survey as described above. In both
treatments, the total payoffs of a participant is the sum of payoffs from all parts of the experiment.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.