Reshaping Beliefs About Ourselves and Others: Experimental Evidence from Civil Servants in Pakistan
How to cite
Mehmood, Sultan; Kaur, Jalnidh; Naseer, Shaheen; Chen, Daniel. 2022. "Reshaping Beliefs About Ourselves and Others: Experimental Evidence from Civil Servants in Pakistan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008786. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8786-1.2000000000000002
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Information frictions on the knowledge of one’s impact can stymie civil servant motivation for the well-being of individuals they serve. We conduct a field experiment among public school teachers in Pakistan. We randomize teachers to receive one of three information treatments. One treatment arm is growth mindset training that student outcomes are elastic and malleable. A second treatment arm presents a narrative about teacher value-added. A third treatment arm presents empirical evidence on teacher value-added. We cross-randomize teachers to receive additional SMS messages to reinforce the training.
Intervention
Our intervention targets these misperceived social norms through a combination of information provision and exposure to a role-model. We individually randomize 400 teachers to one of the below arms:
Arm A (Growth Mindset Treatment): Teachers are exposed to a first-generation learner from a similar background as their students, who fought odds to achieve heights in their academic and professional career.
Arm B (Narrative Treatment): Teachers are exposed to a role-model who acknowledges the role of primary school teachers in their life. (anecdotal value-added)
Arm C (Evidence Treatment): Teachers are exposed to information about the role of primary school teachers based on empirical evidence.
Arm D (Placebo): Teachers are exposed to a training of similar length and format as other arms on a neutral topic.
Experimental design
Our intervention targets these misperceived social norms through a combination of information provision and exposure to a role-model. We individually randomize 400 public school teachers to one of the below arms:
Arm A (Growth Mindset Treatment): Teachers are exposed to a first-generation learner from a similar background as their students, who fought odds to achieve heights in their academic and professional career.
Arm B (Narrative Treatment): Teachers are exposed to a role-model who acknowledges the role of primary school teachers in their life. (anecdotal value-added)
Arm C (Evidence Treatment): Teachers are exposed to information about the role of primary school teachers based on empirical evidence.
Arm D (Placebo): Teachers are exposed to a training of similar length and format as other arms on a neutral topic.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.