‘What’s the bleeding problem?’ Menstrual health policy and consequential attitudes in India

How to cite

Garikipati, Supriya; Phillips-Howard, Penelope. 2022. "‘What’s the bleeding problem?’ Menstrual health policy and consequential attitudes in India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008767. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8767-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Supriya Garikipati* , Penelope Phillips-Howard

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008767
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8767-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2017-07-10 – 2018-05-25
Countries
India (Telangana)
Secondary IDs
Safa0317R; RETH000734
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8767

Abstract

In a bid to improve menstrual health outcomes in LMICs, state policies and civic society have determinedly promoted the take up of disposable pads, at the neglect of less polluting sustainable and cheaper alternatives. This oversight is problematic as it contributes to the increased burden of waste management, and denies women the right to informed choice. Using an experimental approach, this study seeks to examine the effects of exposure to sustainable alternatives compared with disposable pads on women’s attitudes to menstrual materials and practices. We test the hypothesis that such exposure positively effects women’s preferences and attitudes to more sustainable alternatives versus disposable pads.

The study will be conducted across 10 sites in the city of Hyderabad, Telangana with the help of 2 facilitating grass-roots NGOs (Safa and KGNMT). We will use a community participation methodology that carefully considers the cultural context and policy backdrop in which decisions on menstrual products and practices are made.

The basic design is to recruit 500 women (50 from each site) and randomly allocate them to one of the three conditions using the ration 1:2:2: information only (C1); information + reusable material (C2); information + disposable pad (C3). After baseline survey, we will provide each of the three conditions with information on menstrual hygiene and alternative materials. Those in C2 and C3 will be provided with relevant menstrual material sufficient for 6 months of use. End line will be carried out after 6 months. At both baseline and end line we will collect information on various menstrual outcomes including knowledge; preferred material; menstrual practices (access, use and disposal). Primary outcome will be preference, with secondary outcomes being knowledge and attitudes to use and disposal.

Intervention

There were three study conditions: (1) Disposable arm provided with disposable pads and complete information on the full range of menstrual alternatives, their hygienic use and correct disposal; (2) Reusable arm was given cloth-pads and information on menstrual products; and (3) Inform-only arm, continued with usual practice and received same information. The current study analyses the time points directly before for all conditions (baseline), and after the women completed six months of product use (follow-up). Follow-up is used for comparisons between disposable pads to reusable cloth-pads to inform-only.

All study participants received complete information on the entire range of menstrual alternatives along with their hygienic use and correct disposal. For the two product conditions, participants also received sufficient menstrual products for six months. To achieve community acceptance, the products used in the trial had to be selected carefully and with the involvement of the NGOs. A careful selection exercise was undertaken which assessed two products as viable for the community trial: a pad that required burial to compost (‘Disposable’ condition) and a reusable cloth-pad with an anti-microbial top layer (‘Reusable’ condition). The selection process and additional information about the products are detailed in in Appendix A, Box A2.
This gave us the three study arms: information + disposable pad (Disposable condition); information + reusable cloth-pad (Reusable condition); and information only + usual practice (Inform-only condition). After allocation to study conditions, baseline was completed, and menstrual materials distributed to Disposable and Reusable arms. All interactions were administered by pairs of women, one of whom was an employee of the partner NGOs. Most individual interviews were carried out in respondent’s home, but where women preferred it, these were done in partner NGOs’ office.

Experimental design

The study design included repeat cross-sectional surveys over six months to quantify the effects of providing women with complete information about period products compared with combining knowledge provision with reusable cloth pad or disposable pads on women’s preferences for menstrual materials and practices.

In consultation with partner NGOs, ten areas were identified to achieve a mix of geographical spread, access to amenities and other considerations like safety of enumerators, accessibility etc. From each of the study sites, a random sample of 50 households was created. From this list, we removed households that were known to reside in the area only intermittently and households that had no women in the age group 18-45 years of age. Using stratified random sampling, the remaining women were allocated to one of the three study conditions using the ratio of 4 women to product plus information condition for every 1 woman to the information only condition.

Design details

Randomization method
Public lottery in presence of study partners (done in office)
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
10 sites across the city of Hyderabad, Telangana
Observations
500
Arms
Stratified random sampling was used in this pilot to allocate women to one of the three study conditions: Disposable (n = 200), Reusable (n = 200) and control Inform-only (n = 100). As the main aim of the study was to quantify the effects of exposure to reusable alternatives to disposable pads, the control inform-only condition was kept smaller than the two arms providing menstrual products. Information on the range of menstrual materials was provided to women across all three conditions.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome is a measure of women’s preference for reusable menstrual products. This outcome measure was chosen as the main aim of the study to understand the effect of exposing women to alternatives to disposable pads on their preference for menstrual products.
Secondary outcomes
We also included three secondary outcomes: women’s willingness to adapt menstrual practices in terms of use and disposal; a measure of women’s awareness of products beyond traditional cloth and disposable pads; and a measure of women’s beliefs about menstruation and menstrual products, including their beliefs about the need for drying cloth in direct sunlight. These outcomes were chosen because in combination they encompassed women’s attitudes towards menstrual materials and practices that are more sustainable than using disposable pads.
Sponsors
Name: EPSRC (UK) Global Challenges Research Fund 2016/17 (Ref No. 141131). Location: United Kingdom Url: https://epsrc.ukri.org/
Partners
Name: Safa (India) Partner_type: ngo Url: https://www.safaindia.org/ Name: KGNMT Partner_type: ngo Url: http://www.kgnmtrust.com/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords