Evaluating the impact of a national financial education campaign delivered via television and social media: Experimental evidence from Italy
How to cite
Kaiser, Tim; Lusardi, Annamaria; Sconti, Alessia; Zia, Bilal. 2022. "Evaluating the impact of a national financial education campaign delivered via television and social media: Experimental evidence from Italy." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008743. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8743-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
A growing literature in economics studies the causal effects of media exposure on individual behavior (see DellaVigna and Ferara 2015 for a narrative review). The outcomes domains studied are diverse and cover crime (Dahl and DellaVigna 2009, ) health (Vaughan et al. 2000, La Ferrara et al. 2012, Kearney and Levine 2015, Trudeau 2016, Banerjee et al. 2019, Breza et al. 2021), education, empowerment and labor-market outcomes (Zavodny 2006, Chong and La Ferrara 2009, Jensen and Oster 2009, Ravallion et al. 2015, Bjorvatn et al. 2019, Kearney and Levine 2019), and financial decision making (Baker and George 2010, Berg and Zia 2017).
In the context of financial education, evidence from South Africa suggests that edutainment is an effective way to foster individual financial decision making (see Berg and Zia 2017) with realized treatment effects being larger, on average, than what is being found in recent meta-analyses of financial education field experiments (Miller et al. 2015, Kaiser and Menkhoff 2017, Kaiser et al. 2020). Edutainment may be seen as an especially promising avenue for financial education, as marginal costs of these interventions are generally low and the interventions appear to be well suited to operate at scale. While the available empirical evidence suggests that media (especially television and social media) can impact individual field behaviors in a meaningful way, the mechanisms leading to behavior change are less well understood. Against this backdrop, we test leading hypotheses of media impact regarding three disctinct channels (a) information provision, (b) role modeling and preference change via emotional connections, and (c) increased salience and basic awareness (see La Ferrara 2016).
To this end, we conduct a randomized encouragement experiment with a representative sample of over 3800 individuals in Italy offering monetary incentives to follow elements of a national campaign designed to foster financial literacy. We randomly allocate the individuals to one of four experimental conditions: (a) C: pure control (i.e., no encouragement), (b) T1: monetary encouragement to follow a popular soap-opera with financial messaging embedded into the story line (i.e., the role-modelling channel), T2: monetary incentive to follow a popular quiz show with questions related to financial decision-making posed within the show (i.e., the information provision channel), and (c) T3: a monetary incentive to follow a low-intensity social and traditional media campaign relying on a female fictional character communicating simple but salient and intiuitive messages about financial decision making (i.e., the salience and basic awareness channel). In addition to studying the relative effectiveness of these campaign elements, we are interested in heterogenous treatment effects by gender, baseline financial knowledge / education, and socio-economic background. Additionally, we are interested in the potential role of cognitive vs. non-cognitive process outcomes in mediating the observed treatment effects.
The results of our study are expected to be contributions to the literature on effective and scalable financial education policies and to the literature on persuasion and causal effects of media exposure more generally.
Intervention
The Financial Education Campaign promoted by the Italian Edufin Committee aims to raise awareness of the need to increase the financial skills of Italian citizens to make conscious financial choices. The national campaign, launched in October 2021 and concluded in the first half of December 2021, includes the following treatment components:
- a product placement campaign with the inclusion of educational references in the field of planning and financial choices within the TV series “Un Posto al Sole” (T1) and the television program 'L'Eredità' (T2) broadcast on RAI networks;
- a cross-media communication campaign on television, radio, press, digital spaces and social media focused on the figure of Sofia (T3), a fictional female character promoting knowledge and information on economic and financial issues to make more informed choices.
In particular, the issues that the campaign deals with are related to the importance of financial planning (savings, investments, financing, pensions, insurance) promoting responsible financial behaviors, i.e.:
o making informed financial choices (savings, loans and investments, insurance and pensions);
o dealing with unexpected shocks (savings, financing, insurance);
o planning for the future and making conscious intertemporal choices (investments, loans, savings, retirement planning and insurance)
o taking care of ones own finances (connection decisions and financial well-being).
Experimental design
We employ a randomized encouragement design to study the impact of different elements of the national financial literacy campaign on financial knowledge, awareness, attitudes, and behaviors. We randomly assign participants in a nationally representative panel to one of four conditions: (a) pure control, (b) T1 (Soap Opera), (c) T2(Quiz Show), or (d) Social Media campaign. We encourage viewership/following of the campaign elements by offering monetary incentives to watch the TV content / the social media content and follow-up with respondents after episodes have aired. We ask respondents questions about the content of the episodes / campaign week to measure take-up and compliance with the encouragement treatments. In a midline (immediately after the campaign ends) and an endline survey (about 6 to 12 months later) we assess treatment effects on primary and secondary outcomes and study how attitudes, awareness and/or financial knowledge may mediate the treatment effects of the respective campaign elements.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.