The Organization and Impact of Relational Sourcing on Smallholder Farmers in the Rwanda Coffee Sector

How to cite

Steenkamp, Iris; Macchiavello, Rocco; Abouaziza, Mohamed. 2022. "The Organization and Impact of Relational Sourcing on Smallholder Farmers in the Rwanda Coffee Sector." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008725. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8725-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Iris Steenkamp* , Rocco Macchiavello , Mohamed Abouaziza

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008725
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8725-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2021-10-01 – 2022-10-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D22, L14, O12, Q13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8725

Abstract

Agricultural chains are characterized by imperfect markets and contract enforcement. Under these circumstances, buyers and sellers benefit from long-term relationships based on mutual trust. While recent research has made progress in understanding the functioning of these relationships, little is known about how successful relationships can be established, organized, and deployed at scale to benefit smallholder farmers in a cost-effective way. In partnership with a leading coffee exporter, we have set up a pilot in which we design, implement and evaluate the impact of a farmer development program that aims to build relationships between farmers and the company.

Intervention

In partnership with a leading coffee exporter, we set up a pilot study in which we design, implement and evaluate the impact of a Farmer Development Program (FDP) in the Rwanda coffee chain.

First, we evaluate the impact of the FDP on the farmers eligible to join the program using a regression-discontinuity-design (RDD). We examine the spill-over of the FDP program on farmers initially not invited to join the FDP program randomizing the share of farmers eligible to join FDP across zones. Additionally, using experimental methods, we examine the differential impact of two relationship-building organizational interventions embedded into the FDP: i) a relationship manager and ii) a communication intervention.

In this pilot project, we roll out the FDP in four washing stations. We plan to roll out the program to additional coffee washing stations based on the learnings.

Experimental design

The empirical strategy of this pilot project consists of a combination of quasi-experimental and experimental methods. We focus on the following three elements: i) the impact of the FDP, ii) the spillover effect of the FDP, and iii) the impact of relationship-building interventions.

First, we evaluate the impact of the FDP. All farmers in the catchment areas are scored at baseline based on deliveries and other observable characteristics. Our sample is split into two groups: 60% of the farmers above the corresponding threshold within their zones (FDP treatment), and the remaining 40% of farmers scoring below the threshold (FDP control). To overcome potential self-selection bias, we exploit the fact that all farmers were scored against pre-determined criteria and were not able to ex-ante manipulate scores to participate in the FDP. By focusing on those farmers just above and below the threshold, we can use a regression discontinuity design (RDD) framework to causally identify the FDP impacts.

Second, we randomized 32 zones in our sample frame into two groups. The first group includes 16 zones with 80% invited farmers (high-intensity zones), and the second group covers 16 zones with 40% invited farmers to the FDP (low-intensity zones). Focusing on the bottom 20% of the farmers in terms of farmer score, this empirical design permits to measure the spillover effects by controlling for the intensity of invited farmers (40% or 80%) within each zone.

Third, we evaluate the impact of two organizational relationship-building interventions using experimental methods. We assess whether having a designated “fixed” relationship manager and whether communication by a familiar versus unfamiliar individual affects the main outcomes.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer using software STATA.
Randomization unit
* Stage 1: FDP Farmer Selection * STRATA: CWS x Zone x Gender * Stage 2: RDD farmer selection * STRATA: CWS x Farmer score * Stage 3: Relationship Building Intervention * a. Relationship manager intervention STRATA: CWS x Zone x Gender b. Communication Intervention STRATA: RM Treatment x Zone x Session
Clusters
* Stage 1: FDP Farmer Selection * - 32 zones across 4 CWS * Stage 2: RDD farmer Selection * * Stage 3: Relationship-building intervention * - 285 session groups in 32 zones across 4 CWS, each group consists of 10 farmers
Observations
Stage 1: FDP Sample size ~ 4900 farmers * Stage 2: RDD farmer Selection * * Stage 3: Relationship-building intervention * Sample size ~2960 farmers
Arms
** Stage 1: FDP Farmer Selection ** * a. FDP RCT - FDP treatment ~ 2960 farmers - FDP control ~ 1940 farmers * b. FDP Intensity - Low intensity zone ~ 2450 farmers [16 zones] - High intensity zone ~ 2450 farmers [16 zones] ** Stage 2: RDD farmer Selection ** ** Stage 3: Relationship-building intervention ** * a. Relationship Manager Intervention - Fixed RM ~ 990 farmers [95 groups] - Placebo RM ~ 990 farmers [95 groups] - Control RM ~ 980 farmers [95 groups] * b. Communication Intervention ---- - SMS ~ 724 farmers - Fixed RM call ~ 743 farmers - Placebo RM call ~ 741 farmers - Call center call ~ 751 farmers
Primary outcomes
1. Farmer attendance at sessions and engagement with call center. 2. Adoption of agricultural practices 3. Coffee cherry delivery (KG)
Secondary outcomes
1. Clarity on FDP program expectations and benefits 2. Trust in CWS 3. Traceability of transactions 4. Quality of deliveries

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords