The Habit-Forming Effects of Feedback: Evidence from a Large-Scale Field Experiment
How to cite
Byrne, David; Martin, Leslie; Goette, Lorenz. 2021. "The Habit-Forming Effects of Feedback: Evidence from a Large-Scale Field Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008720. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8720-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We propose an attention-based mechanism for habit formation and contrast its predictions with those from Stigler and Becker (1977)’s consumption-based mechanism. We develop a habit formation model that nests both mechanisms and structurally estimate it using real-time feedback and consumption data from a large-scale field experiment in shower water consumption. Identification comes from a novel experimental design that varies real-time feedback cycles that temporarily draw attention to individu- als’ water consumption costs. Using the model, we validate an attention-based mechanism, show that attention-based habits form quickly and decay slowly, and uncover a new solution concept for optimizing feedback interventions to create sustained behavioral change.
Intervention
We explore a new behavioral mechanism for habit that we call attentional habit formation. To this end, we develop a model of attention-based habit formation and design and implement a large-scale field experiment to test the model’s predictions and structurally estimate its parameters. With the estimated model, we examine how attentional habits build up and decay and study the design of policy interventions with personalized feedback for creating robust habits. Throughout, Stigler and Becker (1977)'s model provides a natural benchmark for our analysis. We document stark contrasts between their model and ours in terms of empirical performance and implications for policy intervention design.
Experimental design
Sample structure
- 7 experimental conditions (T1, T2, T3, T4, T5, T6, T7)
- 100 households per experimental condition
- 130 showers per individual
Experimental Design
"noFB" denotes no real-time feedback on shower water usage from an Amphiro B1 smart shower meter
"FB" denotes real-time feedback on shower water usage from an Amphiro B1 smart shower meter
- T1: 10 noFB, 120 noFB
- T2: 10 noFB, 120 FB
- T3: 10 noFB, 48 FB, 72 noFB
- T4: 10 noFB, 24 FB, 48 noFB, 24 FB, 24 noFB
- T5: 10 noFB, 12 FB, 24 noFB, 12 FB, 24 noFB, 12 FB, 24 noFB, 12 FB
- T6: 10 noFB, 6 FB, 12 noFB, 6 FB, 12 noFB, 6 FB, 12 noFB, 6 FB, 12 noFB, 6 FB, 12 noFB, 6 FB, 12 noFB, 6 FB, 12 noFB
- T7: 10 noFB, 3 FB, 15 noFB, 3 FB, 15 noFB, 3 FB, 15 noFB, 3 FB, 15 noFB, 3 FB, 15 noFB, 3 FB, 15 noFB, 3 FB, 15 noFB
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.