Reactive Sticks A Randomized Control Trial on the Effects of Sunk Costs on Completions Rates of a Substance-Use-Disorder Self-Help Program

How to cite

Mattiacci, Giuseppe Dari; Ayres, Ian; Goudriaan, Anneke. 2021. "Reactive Sticks A Randomized Control Trial on the Effects of Sunk Costs on Completions Rates of a Substance-Use-Disorder Self-Help Program." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008713. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8713-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Giuseppe Dari Mattiacci* , Ian Ayres , Anneke Goudriaan

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008713
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8713-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2021-12-13 – 2022-03-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I12, K10
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8713

Abstract

Online substance-use-disorder treatment programs face the common challenge of keeping individuals committed to their initial goals to complete the program. In this study, we experimentally test the effect of sunk costs on resolve to complete the program and achieve self-set goals. We focus on subjects with use-disorder concerning an array of substances and activities — alcohol, cannabis, gambling, cocaine, smoking — who voluntarily enroll in a free online self-help program consisting of several modules. We manipulate the “cost” of participation in the program by varying the ease with which subjects can (1) start module 1 and (2) transition from module 1 to module 2. We hypothesize that those subjects who faced higher sunk costs of participation will display (1) higher rates of program completion, (2) longer program engagement as compared to a control group, (3) higher rates of achievement of self-set goals, (4) reduced cravings, and (5) higher self-reported motivation. We will also be able to assess whether flat or escalating temptations are more effective in cementing resolve. Finally, we will run a heterogeneity analysis and a voluntary post-experimental survey.

Intervention

Individuals in the treatment groups will be asked to complete a standard slider task, in order to have subject exert effort in a way that is as uniform as possible across individuals. (Gill & Prowse https://web.ics.purdue.edu/~gill53/GillProwseSliders.pdf)

The task consists of several sliders positioned at 0, which have to be repositioned at the mid-point using the mouse, trackpad or touch screen.

Low-effort version: 20 sliders
High-effort version: 40 sliders

Experimental design

Jellinek offers an online self-help program targeted at individuals that self-report the wish to diminish use or quit alcohol, smoking, cannabis, cocaine or gambling. The program is anonymous and free of charge for participants and consists of several modules

Rough data: 85% fails to finish the program. Yet of the 15% who finishes does not necessarily reach their goal.

At the start, subjects communicate their use and their goal (quit, reduce use, …). At the end, they report their use (hence one can assess whether they reached their goal).

The experiment will run for 1.5 months — from 13 December 2021 to 31 January 2022 — and the data collection will take place until 30 March 2022 in order to follow the performance of all subjects, including those who enrolled towards the end of the trial period.

It is crucial that during this period no changes be made to the program.

Subjects will be randomly allocated to 1 of 4 groups:
1. Control group: Motivation / cravings rating before the start and at the end of module 1.
2. Condition A: At enrollment: motivation / cravings rating followed by low-effort task. At the end of module 1: motivation / cravings rating and no task.
3. Condition B: At enrollment: motivation / cravings rating followed by low-effort task. At the end of module 1: motivation / cravings rating followed by low-effort task.
4. Condition C: At enrollment: motivation / cravings rating followed by low-effort task. At the end of module 1: motivation / cravings rating followed by high-effort task.

The idea of the treatments is to test the effect of having to overcome a small hurdle before being able to go on with the program. Condition A tests the effectiveness of one intervention. Condition B tests whether repeating the effort task a second time further boosts resolve. The first and the second tasks have the same degree of difficulty. Condition C tests the effect of escalating the difficulty of the task from the first to the second intervention.

Design details

Randomization method
Computerized randomization, blocked per condition.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
We expect a total sample size of about 1200 subjects based on enrollment in 2020 (9255 subjects) and an intervention period of 1.5 months. We expect the sample to be composed as follows: 33% alcohol, 29% smoking, 21% cannabis, 9% cocaine and 8% gambling.
Observations
1200 individuals
Arms
300
Primary outcomes
Quit rates at intervention points, completion rate and length of engagement with the program (number of modules completed and time elapsed from the start to the last completed task), self-assessment about reaching initially stated goals, self-reported level of cravings, motivation rating at the end of module 1.
Secondary outcomes
heterogeneity analysis

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords