A Day in the Future: the impact of role models on children’s aspirations.

How to cite

Ghisolfi, Selene; Lupi, Federica; Marcolongo, Giovanna; Dimastrochicco, Raffaella; Lemoglie, Marco. 2021. "A Day in the Future: the impact of role models on children’s aspirations.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008698. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8698-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Selene Ghisolfi* , Federica Lupi , Giovanna Marcolongo , Raffaella Dimastrochicco , Marco Lemoglie

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008698
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8698-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2021-12-16 – 2022-12-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8698

Abstract

Kids from poor neighborhoods have typically lower career aspirations than kids from well-off neighborhoods. The gap in aspirations translates into a discrepancy in human capital investment, which causes poverty traps. The aim of this research project is to test whether showing young students the successful careers of professionals who come from the same high-poverty, high-crime neighborhood affects the children’s aspirations and school choices.
Our intervention will target an elementary and middle school in Naples, in a neighborhood with high levels of both poverty and crime. We target students from grades three to eight. Hence, we target students who have not chosen their academic path yet, but who are approaching (some more than others) the choice of high school.
We are organizing a Career Day during the Fall term of the school year. During the Career Day, professionals who come from that neighborhood will share their stories, each of them during a 20-minute presentation. The professionals are people who earned a college degree and are currently employed in a variety of jobs (e.g., as an accountant or psychologist). In his or her speech, each professional will detail his or her current job, the academic path that led to it, his or her motivation and the challenges he or she had to overcome. After the presentations, there will be a Q&A session.
The intervention will be randomized at the class level, with half class being treated and the other half being in the control group. During the intervention, the students in the control group will follow a class on environmental education. We assess the impact of the intervention on academic achievement, high school choice of the students who are now in grade eight, and self-reported aspirations. If proved to be successful, the project represents a cost-effective tool to promote students’ aspirations while potentially reducing crime rate among teenagers.

Intervention

We are organizing a Career Day during the Fall term of the school year. During the Career Day, professionals who come from that neighborhood will share their stories, each of them during a 20-minute presentation. The professionals are people who earned a college degree and are currently employed in a variety of jobs (e.g., as an accountant or psychologist). In his or her speech, each professional will detail his or her current job, the academic path that led to it, his or her motivation and the challenges he or she had to overcome. After the presentations, there will be a Q&A session.
Children in the control group will watch and discuss a video on the green revolution and the future of the planet.
Both groups will have access to a website describing the event each child has participated in and will have the opportunity to re-access information they might have missed.

Experimental design

We study whether meeting and interacting with young professionals from a similar socio-economic background affects the aspirations of children in grades three to eight.
We run an RCT. We perform a within class randomization, and divide each class in two groups. The treatment group attends a “Career Day”, while the control group participates to a discussion on the environment, “Earth Day”.
During the Career Day (treatment), students will listen to the presentations of four different role models. The role models are young professionals who come from the same neighborhood as the students, earned a college degree and are currently employed. Each role model will talk about his or her job, the academic path that led to it, his or her motivation and the challenges he or she had to overcome. The presentations will take place in person and will be followed by a Q&A session during which students will have the opportunity to interact with the presenters.
During the Earth Day, students will watch two videos. In each of them, a young adult talks about the challenge raised by global warming. Then, a college student will moderate a debate to discuss conscious environmental practices.
In both activities, students will have the chance to meet people who can inspire them – although only the treatment group will focus on potential career paths. Both groups will have the chance to interact either with the speaker or with each other so to avoid to capture a mere “interaction” effect.
We plan to study the effect of the career day on:
1. Effort - administrative data on academic achievement and standardized test scores;
2. Aspirations - self-reported via survey
3. School choice - administrative data.

Design details

Randomization method
Stratified by class, gender and immigration status, done in office by computer program (stata)
Randomization unit
individual
Clusters
360 children approx
Observations
360 (max.)
Arms
180 treated, 180 control children
Primary outcomes
Academic achievement and standardized test scores Self reported aspirations School choice

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords