Social distance and consumer trust

How to cite

Jin, Ye; Huang, Lidingrong. 2022. "Social distance and consumer trust." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008692. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8692-6.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ye Jin* , Lidingrong Huang

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008692
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8692-6.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2022-01-26 – 2022-03-28
Countries
China (Zhejiang)
JEL codes
C93, D91, L81
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8692

Abstract

The present research aims to explore the role social distance plays in facilitating trust among customers of a major online retailer. In the context of online shopping, potential customers can not physically inspect the products they want to buy and they largely rely on the product reviews left by previous buyers for the first-hand insights on the product quality, suitability and decide whether the products are worth buying etc. However, product reviews, regardless how positive they are, will need to be trustworthy in the eyes of the potential buyers to have any effect given that 'fictitious product reviews' are now a wide-spread phenomenon in the competitive e-commerce business. In this setting, we explore whether a key social distance-reducing measure, that is showing the product reviewers' face photo, would enhance the trust between the potential buyer and the past buyer such that the positive reviews left by the past buyer would be more trustworthy and subsequently lead to more sales. The key research question is that, given the first 20 product reviews in the review section of a particular product are positive, would showing the review writers' face image enhance the trustworthiness of the positive reviews and encourage more potential customers to click the 'buy' button after being exposed to the reviews?

Intervention

Our industry partner is a listed e-commerce firm in China and they have two categories of reviews. Category (1) when the product review submitter's face photo is present (as an icon on the left); and Category (2) when the review submitter's face is absent and only a default profile photo (i.e. the firm's animal mascot) is shown.

For a given experimental product, we will create two digital versions of its product detail page on the platform:

1. The control version in which the first 20 reviews the potential buyers see are a) positive but b) the original posters' faces are not shown.
2. The treated version in which the same set of positive reviews is used and the posters' faces are also revealed.

Note that potentially customers who enter the product page will only see one of the two versions listed above. For example, one potential customer may see the first version once on the product page, and the other only sees the second version. Randomisation is done on the individual level using the unique customer IDs. This procedure will randomly create two group of customers with only one of the groups being treated with the social-distance reducing measure.

Experimental design

For a given experimental product, we will create two digital versions of its product page on the online retail platform:

1. The control version in which the first 20 reviews the potential buyers see are a) positive but b) the original posters' faces are not shown.
2. The treated version in which the same set of positive reviews is used and the posters' faces are also revealed.

Note that potentially customers who enter the product page will only see one of the two versions listed above. For example, one potential customer may see the first version once on the product page, and the other only sees the second version. Randomisation is done on the individual level using the unique customer IDs. This procedure will randomly create two group of customers with only one of the groups being treated with the social-distance reducing measure.

We will ensure that our sample does not contain the same subject multiple times (the same subject might place an order on the experimental product on multiple occasions during the same experimental period).

a) The experimental product should be available for sale during the entirety of the experimental period.
b) For sufficient generalisability, the experiment product should be appealing to a wide range of customers.

The baseline variables are: i) the subjects' total spending on the platform, ii) the subjects' previous seven-day spending prior to entering the randomisation process, iii) the subjects' total number of negative reviews posted on the products sold by the firm, iv) the number of different products bought by the subjects during the 14-day period prior to entering the randomisation process. Note that the randomisation process occurs when the potential buyer enters the experimental product's product page.

Design details

Randomization method
A randomisation mechanism/algorithm will be developed to randomly channels potential buyers (upon clicking the experimental product) into two different versions of the product detail page. (Ex-post) Balance checks will be performed to ensure that our randomisation process is adequately done.
Randomization unit
Individual customer level
Clusters
Randomisation occurs only at the individual level (i.e., not clustered).
Observations
2000s customers (the exact figure depends on the number of unique customers during the days of intervention).
Arms
Control group: 1000s customers. Treated group: 1000s customers.
Primary outcomes
The subjects' decision to purchase the experimental product(s).
Secondary outcomes
1. The exact amount of the experimental product each subject orders.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords