Impacts of the Chancellor's Emergency Relief Fund on College Students' Performance and Wellbeing

How to cite

Rodriguez-Planas, Nuria. 2021. "Impacts of the Chancellor's Emergency Relief Fund on College Students' Performance and Wellbeing." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008649. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8649-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Nuria Rodriguez-Planas*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008649
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8649-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2020-04-01 – 2025-06-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I23 I 24 J15 I14
Secondary IDs
RSF Grant#: 2007-26767
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8649

Abstract

To provide rapid-response financial support so the most vulnerable and disenfranchised students could cover their basic living expenses and to help ensure that they could remain in school and complete their degrees as the pandemic and its economic consequences continued to unfold, The City University of New York (CUNY) offered the Chancellor’s Emergency Relief (CER) grant program, a one-time $500 lottery-based grant targeted to undocumented and low-income students. During the Spring 2020 semester, 4,000 qualifying students received the grant. The recipients were chosen randomly from a pool of about 20,000 students who were eligible and had applied to the program. To be eligible students had to: (1) seek a degree at CUNY during the school year 2019-20, and (2) belong to one of the following groups: undocumented or low-income students. In the case of low-income students, eligibility was determined by being within 12 credits of earning an undergraduate degree, and either having an Expected Family Contribution (EFC) of zero on their federal financial aid application (FAFSA) or being a parent with any EFC. In contrast, undocumented students did not have to be within certain credits of graduation to be eligible, and they could be seeking an undergraduate or graduate degree. Eligible students amounted to close to 10% of the CUNY student population. Using academic administrative records, we exploit the randomization in the distribution of the CER grant program to evaluate the short- and medium-term impacts this one-time cash grant has on students’ academic persistence, academic performance, and degree completion up to two years after grant receipt. Using survey data, we explore the potential mechanisms behind these findings, including online-learning challenges, child- or family-care, employment stability, anxiety and stress, and food, housing and financial insecurity, among other potential explanations. Our findings will be helpful in shaping policies to anticipate and respond to future challenges, especially among the most underserved populations of students in New York City.

Intervention

The City University of New York (CUNY) offered the Chancellor’s Emergency Relief (CER) grant program, a one-time $500 lottery-based grant targeted to undocumented and low-income students. During the Spring 2020 semester, 4,000 qualifying students received the grant. The recipients were chosen randomly from a pool of about 20,000 students who were eligible and had applied to the program. To be eligible students had to: (1) seek a degree at CUNY during the school year 2019-20, and (2) belong to one of the following groups: undocumented or low-income students. In the case of low-income students, eligibility was determined by being within 12 credits of earning an undergraduate degree, and either having an Expected Family Contribution (EFC) of zero on their federal financial aid application (FAFSA) or being a parent with any EFC. In contrast, undocumented students did not have to be within certain credits of graduation to be eligible, and they could be seeking an undergraduate or graduate degree. Eligible students amounted to close to 10% of the CUNY student population. Using academic administrative records, we exploit the randomization in the distribution of the CER grant program to evaluate the short- and medium-term impacts this one-time cash grant has on students’ academic persistence, academic performance, and degree completion up to two years after grant receipt. Using survey data, we explore the potential mechanisms behind these findings, including online-learning challenges, child- or family-care, employment stability, anxiety and stress, and food, housing and financial insecurity, among other potential explanations.

Experimental design

The recipients were chosen randomly from a pool of about 20,000 students who were eligible and had applied to the program. There were two waves. Eligibility requirements varied by wave. In Wave 1, to be eligible students had to: (1) seek an Associate or Bachelor's degree at CUNY and be registered during the Spring 2020 semester and be within 12 credits of graduating; (2) belong to one of the following groups: International students, undocumented students, or low-income students; and (3) not be receiving work-study funds, veteran’s benefits, or foster care benefits. Low-income students were defined as having an Expected Family Contribution (EFC) of zero on their federal financial aid application (FAFSA) if not a parent, or being a parent with any EFC. In Wave 2, there were three groups of students. Those who were eligible in Wave 1 and did not get the grant; and undocumented or international students 18 or older seeking a degree (including a graduate or professional degree) in Spring 2020. The distribution of the grants in Wave 2 was as follows: 20% for Wave 1 non-recipients, regardless of whether they applied in Wave 1; 70% for undocumented students; and 10% for international students. Application fields were April 6 to 10 2020 for Wave 1 and May 5 to 10 for Wave 2. Award dates were April 20, 2020 for Wave 1, and May 18, 2020 for Wave 2. In Wave 1: 14,248 eligible; 8,257 applied; and 2,000 grants distributed. In Wave 2: 23,420 eligible; 13,757 applied; and 2,000 grants distributed.

Design details

Randomization method
Lottery
Randomization unit
Individual randomization
Clusters
There are no clusters
Observations
In Wave 1, 10,257 students of which 2,000 were treated. In Wave 2, 15,757 students of which 2,000 were treated.
Arms
In Wave 1, 8,257 students in control group and 2,000 students in treatment group. In Wave 1, 13,757 students in control group and 2,000 students in treatment group.
Primary outcomes
College graduation, enrollment in college, not enrolled and not graduated. These three outcomes, which add to 100%, will be measured at different points in time: Fall 2020, Spring 2021, Fall 2021, and so on. Semester GPA, credits take, credits earned, credits dropped (also measured at different points in time). Likelihood of re-enrollment at CUNY to seek a higher degree (for example, a Bachelor's degree after graduating with an Associate degree).
Secondary outcomes
Self-reported wellbeing, financial situation, and employment status (including job loss information); Employment expectations after graduation; Self-reported services and financial assistance received due to COVID-19, and use of aid (saving, consumption, and debt; detailed expenses if used to consume—includes Federal CARES act assistance as well as CER grant; Questions on trust, anxiety, financial, housing and food insecurity; Mental health questions (PHQ-9 and GAD-7)
Sponsors
Name: Russell Sage Foundation co-funded with Carnegie Corporation of New York Location: New York City Url: https://www.russellsage.org/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords