Effect of different interventions on attention to financial campaign
How to cite
Rosen, Maya Haran; Sade, Orly. 2021. "Effect of different interventions on attention to financial campaign." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008644. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8644-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We use proprietary data, survey data, and a field experiment to study the effect of campaigns to raise awareness about lost and forgotten retirement savings accounts. The campaigns were a centralized database to help individuals find inactive accounts, and a tax exemption to encourage individuals to close small inactive accounts and avoid new fees that would exhaust the savings. We show that after the campaigns, inactive retirement accounts still received limited attention. This was more pronounced for individuals with low socioeconomic status and low financial literacy. A controlled field experiment suggests that interventions using more personal interactions can increase attention.
Intervention
We conducted a field experiment that investigated the effectiveness of different communication methods on the awareness and actions of an underprivileged population in Israel: Ultra-Orthodox Jewish women with low objective and subjective financial literacy. The women were recruited from a class at a college for Ultra-Orthodox Jewish women. Ultra-Orthodox Jewish women tend to marry young and undertake paid work to support their husbands, who commit to full time religious study. For our experiment, we used the launch of the “Money Mountain 2” campaign in 2017. Like the original Money Mountain campaign, Money Mountain 2 was launched to help the population find inactive accounts and had the same website as the original Money Mountain, but it extended this service from the retirement savings accounts to other types of bank accounts.
In the field experiment, the interventions we tested included personal and non-personal digital and non-digital interventions (Laudenbach et al. 2018): (1) no intervention (for the control group), (2) an e-mail explanation of the financial campaign, (3) an e-mail explanation together with a video explanation featuring a professional actor, (4) a face-to-face explanation of the financial regulation given by an employee of the Bank of Israel (the organization in charge of banking regulation), and (5) an e-mail explanation given to part of the control group after they had filled out a baseline survey. This last intervention enabled us to isolate the effect of an e-mail on a group that had had an earlier encounter with a Bank of Israel employee (who handed out a baseline survey). We ran a survey on each group following the interventions to investigate their effectiveness.
Experimental design
All participants filled out at least one survey that was used to collect data on individuals’ characteristics and attention to the issue.
The interventions we examined in the experiment are as follows:
1. No intervention: Control group only filled out a baseline survey handed out by an employee of the Bank of Israel during class.
2. E-mail intervention: Received detailed information on the financial regulation in an e-mail and later filled out a survey in person during class.
3. E-mail–video intervention: Received detailed information on the financial regulation in an e-mail, along with a video presentation by a professional actor,90 and later filled out a survey in person during class.
4. Face-to-face intervention: Received a face-to-face explanation of the financial regulation from an employee of the Bank of Israel (the organization in charge of banking regulations) and later filled out a survey in person during class.
5. Double survey–e-mail intervention: Filled out a survey in person handed out by an employee of the bank of Israel during class, received detailed information on the financial regulation in an e-mail, and then filled out the same survey in person for the second time during class.
The e-mail provided (1) detailed instructions on how to access and use the website, (2) an explanation of the steps to take to close accounts if they find inactive funds (e.g., contacting the relevant bank), and (3) a direct link to the website. The video had an actor explain all this information using screenshots from the website. The face-to face explanation provided the same information.
The various interventions described above enable us to test the effectiveness of the mode of communication, in particular digital versus face-to-face. In addition, we examine the dimensional effect of adding a video presentation to an e-mail text, or of having the class meet and interact with a person before receiving more detailed information. The video presentation was 70 seconds (1:10 minutes) long.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.