Managerial or entrepreneurial capital? Untangling constraints of innovative entrepreneurs

How to cite

Leatherbee, Michael; Gonzalez-Uribe, Juanita; Reyes, Santiago. 2021. "Managerial or entrepreneurial capital? Untangling constraints of innovative entrepreneurs." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008641. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8641-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Michael Leatherbee* , Juanita Gonzalez-Uribe , Santiago Reyes

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008641
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8641-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2021-09-17 – 2024-09-09
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8641

Abstract

Entrepreneurial support programs have been implemented over the last decades to foster innovative entrepreneurs in developed and developing countries. Usually, these programs are carried by local business accelerators that provides cash and support services in terms of training, mentorship, access to contacts, among others. While there is some evidence that this type of interventions can foster innovative entrepreneurs , it is still unknown what are the mechanisms that drive the ventures’ growth.

Gonzalez-Uribe and Reyes (2020) explores whether providing support services (training, mentorships, etc.) and no cash have an impact on ventures’ success. This paper finds that innovative entrepreneurs face different constraints besides financial ones. Entrepreneurs that received non-monetary support increased their annual sales by 66% during the three following years after the intervention. However, it is still not clear how those interventions affect the entrepreneurs. Is it because it provides them with managerial capital (a la Bloom and Van Reenen, 2010; Bruhn, Karlan, and Schoar, 2010) so they can run their businesses more efficiently? Or is it because it provides them with entrepreneurial capital (a la Gonzalez-Uribe and Leatherbee, 2018) so they can discover and capture valuable opportunities more effectively?

As well-known practitioners such as Steve Blank have declared, “new ventures are not small versions of large companies.” Implicit in this statement is the idea that the knowledge required to manage a large company is different to the knowledge required to build a new venture. In fact, it implicitly highlights the hypothesis that applying the knowledge that is effective for managing a large company to a new venture can, in fact, be detrimental. Understanding the validity of this hypotheses is paramount for all initiatives that aim at fostering the creation and development of new ventures. If providing entrepreneurs managerial capital is as –or more– effective than providing them with entrepreneurial capital, then many programs that are currently doing so should stick to the status quo. However, if providing managerial capital to entrepreneurs is detrimental and, in contrast, providing them with entrepreneurial capital improves value creation and socioeconomic development, then many entrepreneurship-promotion initiatives may, in fact, require an urgent pivot in their provision of this type of capital.

The answer to this question will have large implications on how to run entrepreneurship support programs. In order to disentangle the effects of managerial versus entrepreneurial capital, we will provide equivalent groups of entrepreneurs unique treatments which aim to endow them with one or the other type of capital. Subsequently, we will compare how each group fares in terms of performance, growth and job creation.

Intervention

A managerial capital intervention will focus in how to run the current company as efficiently as possible, while an entrepreneurial capital intervention will focus on exploring, validating and capturing market needs and business opportunities. On one hand, if entrepreneurs lack managerial capital, the intervention should help entrepreneurs to implement organizational changes such as the establishment of concrete routines, the creation of specific incentives for employees, or improving inventory management. In contrast, an intervention based on entrepreneurial capital should help founders discover and capture higher value opportunities for their products and services, much like the lean startup method induces founders to come up with new business ideas and converge faster on the viability of their ideas (Leatherbee & Katila, 2020). This can be done by providing entrepreneurs with mentors who have an entrepreneurial mindset (e.g., Sarasvathy, 2001; Busenitz and Barney, 1997) and consulting services oriented towards the exploratory stages (as opposed to the exploitative stages) of business creation.

This experiment aims to answer these questions by implementing a Randomized Control Trial (RCT) in Colombia, in collaboration with the Cali Chamber of Commerce (CCC), the same Institution who executed the program where Gonzalez-Uribe and Reyes (2020) find an impact of entrepreneurial schooling under a no-cash design for young businesses. This RCT will provide entrepreneurs with differential treatments: one aimed at improving management practices and making the established opportunity more efficient (i.e., exploitation), while the other one will be aimed at discovery, validation, capture and scaling of novel opportunities (i.e., exploration).

The main objective of this experiment is to identify what type of non-financial capital has the larger impact on start-up performance (i.e., sales, growth, profits and jobs)? And whether that type differs by innovative level of the business idea, characteristics of the entrepreneur, or stage of development of the firm.

Experimental design

The program will be divided into two stages. It is expected to have at least 154 beneficiary companies, these companies will be randomly divided between the two treatment arms.

1. In the first stage, each startup will receive a basic training program (same for the two treatment arms), weekly follow-ups (different focus depending on treatment arm) and 3 hours of support services (different focus depending on treatment arm). The first stage lasts 5 months.
2. After the first stage is completed, a demo day will be held in front of an evaluation panel that will include high-level executives, investors, and ecosystem leaders, among others.
The highest scoring 77 entrepreneurs of each treatment arm will be selected to go to the second phase of the program, for a total of 154 beneficiaries. This second stage will provide the entrepreneurs with 5 consultancy sessions. The focus of the session and who provides the session will be based on the treatment arm of the entrepreneur. The second stage will last 6 months.

Note: if at the time of program implementation there is a larger budget for more beneficiaries, the same rule of dividing the beneficiaries equally between the two treatment arms would apply.

Design details

Randomization method
randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Unit of randomization: firm
Clusters
6 regions of Colombia
Observations
At least 154 firms in total
Arms
The planned number of firms and clusters is 360 (180 per treatment arm). After the completion of the first stage, the second stage will include the top scoring 75 firms of each treatment arm (according to the application scores) for a total of 150 firms and clusters.
Primary outcomes
Short-term outcomes (after the program closure): • Demo-day score: the pitch score as evaluated by judges in the demo-day (see above for more details on demo-day scores) • Change in business practices index as measured by surveys • Change in innovation and openness to new information index as measured by surveys Primary long-term outcomes (within 1 and 2 years of application): • Sales as measured by administrative data and surveys • Business survival as measured by administrative data
Secondary outcomes
Secondary long-term outcomes (within 1 and 2 years of application): • Profits as measured by surveys • Number of employees as measured by surveys and administrative data • Wages as measured by surveys and administrative data • Change in business practices index as measured by surveys • Time dedicated to administrative, exploration and exploitation tasks • Execution of exploration and exploitation activities • Delegation of organizational tasks • Change in innovation and openness to new information index as measured by surveys • Online activity as measured by Alexa • Number of followers on Linkedin, Twitter and/or Facebook (if it applies to the firm) Score of the project (used for selection), and program classification of too entrepreneurs Quality of the business model (innovativeness and scalability) Characteristics of the entrepreneur and its team (education, sex, labor experience, experience as entrepreneur, and skill) Initial stage of the firm (measured in terms of sales) Initial stage of the entrepreneur’s focus (measured in terms if exploration and exploitation focus and activities)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords