Growth Vouchers Programme
How to cite
Overman, Henry. 2022. "Growth Vouchers Programme." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008622. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8622-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Small businesses that seek and obtain strategic business advice are more likely to thrive
and grow. Taking business advice can increase productivity, drive sales and improve the
chance of survival in tough economic times.
Yet as many as three in every ten small businesses in the UK may have an unmet need
for business advice. To date, available evidence is associative, and does not establish a
causal link between small businesses taking business advice and their subsequent higher
growth. No one definitely knows whether it is the advice conferred that enables businesses
to be more likely to prosper, or whether advice and growth are two separate and unrelated
consequences of some other unobserved characteristic or behaviour. This is what Growth
Vouchers will test.
The Growth Vouchers programme is a pioneering government research project that aims
to make it easier for small businesses to access expert advice to help them grow and test
which types of business advice are most effective.
The Growth Vouchers programme will run until March 2015 to attract around 20,000 small
businesses that do not normally use advice. Vouchers worth up to £2,000 each will be
given to a majority of the small businesses who take part to help them pay for advice.
This programme will operate as a Randomised Controlled Trial (RCT), which will enable
the government to obtain a robust assessment of the impact of different types of advice on
participating businesses to be obtained. RCTs are widely regarded as the ‘gold standard’
for empirical research and are used extensively in medicine and international
development. This is the first time that an RCT has been run on such scale anywhere in
the world to explore what business advice works best.
The Growth Vouchers programme will produce real and comprehensive evidence, while
providing benefits for the businesses who take part. This evidence will be used to inform
future policy.
This document sets out how the Growth Vouchers programme will operate, how its design
satisfies the principles of running an RCT and the key questions that we aim to answer. It
then explains what data and analysis will be done to arrive at an answer and the technical
constraints on how robust our answers may be.
Intervention
Eligible firms that completed an online application were offered either an online or personal diagnostic. The diagnostic assessment aimed to establish firm proficiency in each of five areas or ‘themes’ - sales and marketing, raising finance, leadership and management, workforce development and digital technologies. The diagnostic identified one of these themes as an area in which the firm might benefit most from receiving advice. Once a theme of advice was selected, some firms were offered a voucher, capped at £2,000, that could be used to cover up to 50% of cost of the purchased advice. All firms were then referred to an online directory of business advice consultants –developed and run by Enterprise Nation, a business support network for small businesses in the UK.
Experimental design
Firms were eligible if they had been trading for at least one year, had less than 50 employees and had not paid for business advice in the previous three years.
All eligible applicants received a personal or online diagnostic which they had to complete to be considered in the random allocation of vouchers. Allocation to the different diagnostics was randomised: 25% of firms were allocated to an online diagnostic and 75% to a face-to-face or telephone diagnostic.
To complete the diagnostic assessment, firms had to select a theme of advice. Then, they were randomly allocated to a control or treatment group. Randomisation occurred within the theme of advice selected, with 75% of firms allocated to treatment and 25% to the control group. The voucher received by the treatment group could be used to cover 50% of the cost of business support and was capped at £2,000. The total cost depended on the business advice selected. The control group only received the diagnostic (online or personal, depending on the initial randomisation).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.