Does public flood aid crowd out private insurance?
How to cite
Garbarino, Nicola; Schickfus, Marie-Theres von; Neumeier, Florian; Möhrle, Sascha. 2021. "Does public flood aid crowd out private insurance?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008603. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8603-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Policymakers often do not want to promise flood aid ex-ante, to encourage households and firms in flood-prone areas to take up flood insurance. But ex-post, they feel compelled to provide aid to flood victims. This tension is visible in recent policy decisions in Germany, where commitments to stop providing aid were followed by promises to cover most of the damage suffered by the victims of heavy floods in the summer of 2021.
We perform an information treatment where we provide respondents with information about these policy decisions. The sample is split in three groups, which receive, respectively: 1) information about commitments to cut flood aid ("low aid"), 2) actual aid to flood victims ("high aid"), and 3) generic information about flooding world-wide.
We ask expectations of flood aid before and after the information treatment, to check whether expectations are updated. We then ask about two main outcomes: the willingness to pay for private flood insurance, and support for a policy that introduces mandatory flood insurance.
The starting hypotheses are:
1) the high (low) flood aid treatment decreases (increases) both willingness to pay for flood insurance and support for mandatory flood insurance;
2) the effect is concentrated among households that i) express a high concern about flood risk; and ii) update their expectations substantially as a result of the information treatment.
We conduct separate surveys of households (online, across Germany) and firms (both by phone and online, focussing in an area with high flood risk). This trial registration refers to the household survey. The firm survey will be registered separately.
Intervention
Information treatment on a sample of German households.
We provide the following information:
- Group 1 (active control group): % of natural disasters (worldwide) that are due floods or storms
- Group 2 (high flood aid information): households and firms in parts of Germany hit by heavy floods in July 2021 will receive flood aid up to 80% of the damage
- Group 3: (low flood aid information): a number of German states have recently committed to stop providing flood aid
Experimental design
- Sample split in three groups of similar size. Each group gets information about flooding.
- The control group receives generic information about the importance of flooding.
- The two treatment groups receive information about two recent policy decisions in Germany related to flooding. The first policy is the announcement by some German states that they plan to stop providing flood aid (with some exceptions). The second policy is the actual flood aid (80% of damage) promised to the victims of the heavy floods that hit parts of Germany in July 2021.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.