Evaluating the Impact of a Digital Agriculture Advisory Program in India

How to cite

Zhu, Jessica; Cole, Shawn; Goldberg, Jessica; Harigaya, Tomoko. 2021. "Evaluating the Impact of a Digital Agriculture Advisory Program in India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008560. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8560-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jessica Zhu* , Shawn Cole , Jessica Goldberg , Tomoko Harigaya

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008560
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8560-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2021-02-01 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O12, O13, Q16
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8560

Abstract

With the rapid increase in access to mobile phones, there is an increasing effort among governments and policymakers to provide timely and customized agricultural information via mobile phones. However, rigorous evidence on how and for whom such interventions work is still limited. This study aims to understand whether and how agricultural extension delivered via mobile phones increases the agricultural productivity and profitability of smallholder farmers. The research is motivated by the large and persistent yield gap that exists among poor farmers in developing countries. We plan to examine this question using a large-scale randomized controlled trial over a two-year period in one state of India. Moreover, this study will test low-cost approaches to measuring yields. Specifically, it will assess the feasibility of using satellite images to estimate farmers’ rice yields in an eastern state of India. This work will help address a common empirical challenge of evaluating digital extension and other agricultural interventions.

Intervention

Treatment farmers receive access to a toll-free agricultural helpline through which farmers receive interactive voice response (IVR) calls that provide relevant agricultural information based on the agricultural cycle, crop, and weather content, at an approximately weekly schedule. During the Kharif season, treatment farmers receive IVR calls that share agricultural advisories on paddy; during the Rabi season, treatment farmers receive IVR calls with advisories on two crops that farmers have selected.

Moreover, farmers can also use this service to listen to and respond to agricultural questions posed by other farmers, and record their own questions to local agronomists. The use of this service is completely voluntary, and it does not involve any monetary contribution by the farmers.

Experimental design

We use a randomized controlled trial (RCT) to investigate the impact of a digital agricultural advisory service on smallholder farmers’ yield. We recruited eligible households cultivating rice across approximately 903 villages in 19 blocks using a random-walk method and randomly selected half of the households to receive a free digital advisory service.

We selected 19 blocks in five districts in the state for inclusion in the study. All the included blocks had low (<18.5 percent) “penetration” of the information service, as measured by the estimated share of farmers that were enrolled prior to the study, and were covered by the same satellite path. Within these 19 blocks, we selected all villages that met the following criteria during the 2011 Census of India: (i) classified as “rural”; (ii) had more than 50 households; (iii) located in a panchayat with service “penetration” below 10 percent. A total of 1,313 or 39 percent of the villages met these conditions and constituted our study sites. In each village, we selected 5 - 10 percent of households using a random-walk sampling method. Households are eligible for inclusion in the study if they meet a set of criteria and are willing to allow the research team to collect the GPS coordinates of their primary rice plot.

The eligible households (one person per household) are invited to participate in a baseline survey, including questions on demographics, farm characteristics, agricultural knowledge and practice, yield, and GPS coordinates of the primary rice plot.

We then randomize those farmers who have completed the baseline survey and have not registered for this study’s digital extension service before into control and treatment groups. Randomization is conducted at the individual farmer level, and stratified by panchayat group, baseline survey verison, an indicator for participants’ self-reported productivity at baseline being above the median or not, and (for cohort 2 only) an indicator for participants’ gps measured plot size at baseline being above the median or not.

Farmers in the treatment group start to receive free digital advisory service in the coming agriculture season post their baseline survey. Moreover, those farmers are administered a phone-based compensation and service enrollment survey, which collects necessary information to send farmer compensation for their baseline survey participation and explains the digital advisory service to farmers.

The study began implementation of the random walk sampling method in March 2021, but suspended all field operations on 23rd April following a steep rise in COVID-19 cases in the state. 5,204 households were enrolled in the study before the fieldwork suspension (aka “initial” sample, or cohort 1), of which half were randomized to the treatment group and invited to enroll in the information service via phone. 2,571 (99.5%) members of the treatment group (2,602 farmers) opted-in to the service and began receiving advisory messages from 9th June. As the COVID-19 situation alleviated in the study location, we resumed our field activities in October, 2021. We used the same random-walk method in the same locations as previously and sampled a further 8,471 households (aka. cohort 2).

After the 2021-22 and 2022-23 Kharif seasons, we will conduct a midline survey and an endline survey with cohort 1 farmers, allowing us to measure their knowledge, practice, yield and profit.

Design details

Randomization method
We conduct randomization using the Stata program on a computer in an office.
Randomization unit
Individual farmer level.
Clusters
N/A
Observations
Approximate 13,600 rice farmers.
Arms
Control group: approximate 6,800 farmers. Treatment group: approximate 6,800 farmers.
Primary outcomes
Vegetation index, self-reported yield, revenue, and profit, knowledge and adoption indices
Secondary outcomes
Agricultural investment, agricultural diversification, non-agricultural self-employment income generating activities in the household.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords