Are Assessed Risks and Optimism Bias Affected by Partisan Information Cues
How to cite
Wolaver, Amy; Doces, John; Goldberg, Jack. 2021. "Are Assessed Risks and Optimism Bias Affected by Partisan Information Cues." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008547. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8547-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Objective: To determine whether assessed risks to oneself, assessed risks to the general population, and optimism bias about a variety of policy topics are affected by partisan informational cues. Half of the respondents will be randomized to receive a politically neutral version of the risk area and half to a version including a partisan clue. For example, risk of infection from COVID versus risk of infection from the flu; risk from a natural disaster with no attributed cause versus risk from a natural disaster caused by climate change, etc... Respondents will then be asked for their level of support for policies related to each of the topical areas used in the risk assessement.
Intervention
Views about the risk from a variety of policy areas have become increasingly polarized in the United States. Prior research has documented that Democrats rated the risks associated with COVID-19 as much higher than Republicans. Optimism bias, the rating of one’s own risk as lower than a peer’s, is an important correlate with a variety of behaviors and views. We propose to test whether partisan framing cues affect the assessed risk to self, the assessed risk to a peer, and the level of optimism bias for a number of policy issues. For each policy, we randomize between a liberal, conservative or neutral cue (see figure for examples). We include a neutral traffic accident scenario as a control. Following the assessment of risk, we ask for levels of support for policies related to each risk scenario and test for impacts on both COVID-19 and flue vaccination status/intentions.
We will test for the following hypotheses:
COVID-19 will raise the risk assessment for Democrats/liberals/non-Trump voters and depress the risk assessment for Republicans/conservatives/Trump voters.
On the other issues:
Liberal cues will raise the risk assessment for the scenario for Democrats/liberals/non-Trump voters relative to the neutral or conservative cues.
Conservative cues will raise the risk assessment for the scenario for Republicans/conservatives/Trump voters relative to the neutral or conservative cues.
Higher levels of risk assessment will increase support among the partisan group for the related policy action.
Research Questions:
Will the levels of risk-to-self versus risk-to-a-peer be affected differently by the partisan cues (thus affecting optimism bias)?
What effect, if any, will optimism bias have on support for policy action?
Experimental design
Different topical scenarios will be randomized between liberal, conservative and neutral partisan cues in questions assessing the respondent's personal risk and their assessed risk of harm to another, similar person from the scenario.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.