Guaranteed Basic Income in a Rural Setting: Subsidizing Leisure and Reducing Labor Force Participation or Alleviating Poverty Traps?
How to cite
García, Jorge Luis; Warren, Patrick; Watson, Lawrence Reed. 2021. "Guaranteed Basic Income in a Rural Setting: Subsidizing Leisure and Reducing Labor Force Participation or Alleviating Poverty Traps?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008509. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8509-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Guaranteed Basic Income (GBI) is a policy that grants an unconditional cash grant to households or individuals, usually every month. It received attention recently as the main policy proposal of presidential primary candidate Andrew Yang. The 1968 Poor People’s Campaign proposed GBI for the socioeconomically disadvantaged. Economist Milton Friedman also advocated for GBI.
Basic economic theory predicts that guaranteeing a stable source of income decreases labor force participation: A recipient of such income increases their consumption of all goods, including leisure time. This prediction is the reason why GBI has political opposition. More general economic theories predict that GBI potentially releases individuals from poverty traps—where the day-to-day struggle to meet immediate needs means that a single economic shock, like the Covid-19 PANDEMIC, can lead to job loss, eviction, bankruptcy, or reduced health. In a poverty trap, the long-term investments in skills and competency required to escape poverty are extremely risky. GBI can mitigate the investment risks and increase labor force participation in the long term. The opposing theoretical predictions of GBI’s outcomes make an empirical evaluation fundamental for understanding the policy.
The proposed project is based on a 24-month field randomized controlled trial of GBI in rural South Carolina. The project is a collaboration between Clemson University’s John E. Walker Department of Economics’ and Anderson Interfaith Ministries, a non-profit organization in Anderson, South Carolina devoted to providing community services. Anderson Interfaith Ministries (hereinafter “AIM”) seeks to “connect people with support, resources, and education so they can empower themselves to become self-sufficient,” and conducts several programs specifically aimed at bolstering financial stability and educational attainment within the Anderson community, including in some instances direct cash payments to individuals and families.
Intervention
The proposed project is based on a 24-month field randomized controlled trial of GBI in rural South Carolina. The project is a collaboration between Clemson University’s John E. Walker Department of Economics’ and Anderson Interfaith Ministries, a non-profit organization in Anderson, South Carolina devoted to providing community services.
Experimental design
The close relationship of AIM with the pool of potential participants and our conversations with AIM indicate that the take-up when forming our baseline sample will be very high. We aim to have a sample of 100 participants. The randomization approach that we will follow is usual when evaluating the expansion of social policies. For example, it was used in Oregon’s Medicaid health insurance experiment to evaluate Medicaid expansions (Finkelstein et al., 2012). We will stratify the randomization by family (e.g., if a father and son are in the sample of 100 participants, they will both be either in the treatment or control group. We will not have members of the same family with different randomization status).
We will randomize 40 participants to the treatment group and provide them a cash grant of 200 US dollars per month for the duration of the program. The remaining 60 participants are the control or comparison group. They receive 10 dollars per month as an honorarium for answering the baseline and follow-up surveys. Our power calculations across several outcomes indicate that the cash grant is large enough to detect impacts when assuming effects in the confidence-interval lower bound of the estimates reported by SEED (2021). This follows in part because the cash grant will represent a large proportional increase in the annual income of the disadvantaged households that we will target. All of the individuals targeted revolve around the poverty line. The cash grant would thus increase their annual household income by approximately 19%, 14%, and 11% for one-person, two-person, and three-person households, respectively.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.