Understanding Investors’ ESG Preferences: Beliefs, Ambiguity Attitudes and Social Norm

How to cite

Dong, Bin; Bauer, Rob; Jiao, Peiran. 2021. "Understanding Investors’ ESG Preferences: Beliefs, Ambiguity Attitudes and Social Norm." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008508. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8508-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Bin Dong* , Rob Bauer , Peiran Jiao

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008508
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8508-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2021-11-29 – 2022-03-31
Countries
Netherlands ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8508

Abstract

ESG (environmental, social, and governance) factors increasingly attract a tremendous amount of capital and investors’ attention. However, a complete understanding of the underlying drive for this pursuit for high ESG is still lacking to date, both theoretically and practically. The literature so far has solely focused on social preferences, whereas in this project, we propose and investigate a number of important and plausible explanations.

We will launch a field experiment. First, we randomly separate investors into two groups and show them a randomly selected high ESG fund's past annual returns. The intervention group is told the fund's ESG rating is high, but the baseline group doesn't know the fund's ESG information. Then, we measure two groups of beliefs, ambiguity perception, and social norms by adopting novel quantitative methodologies to a survey experiment. Theoretically, we propose investors’ beliefs towards superior performance, lower perceived ambiguity, and norm following of high ESG investments as alternative explanations. Practically, we construct and validate a design to elicit such beliefs, ambiguity perceptions, and social norms efficiently and scientifically.

Our findings will have significant implications for financial institutes and policymakers. For instance, the methods we develop can provide a profiling tool in terms of understanding the true ESG preference of investors, and for policymakers that strive to promote socially responsible investment (SRI). In the meantime, we will also profile index fund investors, in order to find out how they are similar or different in characteristics from other investor classes.

Intervention

We offer the selected funds' ESG information (ESG Rating) to the intervention group.
We hide the selected funds' ESG information (ESG Rating) from the baseline group.

Experimental design

Our survey experiment includes an ESG information treatment to elicit investors' beliefs on ESG assets performance, ambiguity perception on ESG information, and social norms on ESG investing. First, we randomly separate investors into two groups and show them a selected high-ESG rating fund's past performance. Then, we give the fund's high-ESG information to the intervention group and hide the information to the baseline group. After reading the information, investors are asked to predict the following year (short-term) and three-year (long-term) annual returns.

One hundred high-ESG rating funds are randomly selected. The intervention group is told that all of the selected one hundred funds are high-ESG ratings, and the baseline group doesn't have any ESG information. Investors are then asked to predict the proportion of funds' positive returns given one hundred randomly selected funds.

Investors are then asked to rate the social impact of investing behavior described in the survey. The intervention group is asked to evaluate investment of low-ESG, and the baseline group is asked to evaluate investment of high-ESG.

Investors are then asked to select between funds with various ESG attributes (high-ESG, low-ESG), management type (passive, active), risk classification (high, middle, low), and expected returns.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done within the survey platform, oTree.
Randomization unit
Randomization unit (questions' orders) is done within the survey program by oTree.
Clusters
We plan to distribute the survey to 15000 investors in the Netherlands.
Observations
We plan to collect 1500 valid survey responses.
Arms
We will have two treatment groups: baseline group and intervention group. We will have 650 observations per group.
Primary outcomes
We measure two groups of outcome variables: 1) Beliefs on high-ESG funds' performance 2) Ambiguity Perception on ESG information 3) Social norms on ESG investing 4) Social preferences

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords