Evaluation of a Support Program for Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises in Côte d'Ivoire

How to cite

Lakemann, Tabea; Beber, Bernd; Lay, Jann; Priebe, Jan. 2021. "Evaluation of a Support Program for Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises in Côte d'Ivoire." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008492. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8492-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Tabea Lakemann* , Bernd Beber , Jann Lay , Jan Priebe

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008492
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8492-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2021-04-01 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
L26, M41, M50, J24, J81
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8492

Abstract

Business support programs, such as classroom-based training or consulting services, are widely used by developing country governments to enhance the performance of small-scale enterprises. Although job creation and the central role of the small business sector for overall employment are one common justification for implementing such programs, they are often not designed to target employment outcomes directly and few studies have established a clear link between business support interventions and job creation or employment quality. We conduct a rigorous impact evaluation of a support program for micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs) in Côte d’Ivoire. The program will deliver consulting services to 250 Ivorian MSMEs over the duration of six months and focuses on the dimensions of financial management and human resource management. Beneficiary MSMEs are selected randomly from the pool of more than 450 MSMEs who applied to participate in the program, passed the eligibility assessment, and responded to a baseline survey. Our evaluation covers key outcomes at two levels. At the firm level, we will consider (i) employment in quantitative terms, (ii) employment security and quality, (iii) HR management practices, (iv) firm performance, (v) capital and labor productivity, (vi) access to finance and financial constraints, as well as (vii) financial management practices. At the individual level, outcomes are (i) employment, (ii) employment quality, and (iii) mobility.

Intervention

The Programme d’Appui à la Productivité (PAP-PME) offers six months of consulting support to Ivorian Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs). While the program also targets overall business performance and productivity, there is a strong, politically mandated emphasis on creating and improving employment. The third and final cohort of the program, which is at the center of this evaluation, offers consulting support primarily in the areas of financial management and human resource (HR) management. Should the PAP-PME be continued, the evaluation may be extended to include one or more future cohorts.

Experimental design

The implementing agency advertised the program nationwide using its network of local representations as well as business associations. In total, 576 interested enterprises (excluding double submissions and beneficiaries of earlier cohorts) from different regions in Côte d’Ivoire submitted application documents in March 2021, 503 of which were identified as fulfilling the eligibility criteria of at least one year of existence and having at least one employee. These 503 MSMEs received an email congratulating them on their admission to the program and inviting them to a virtual program inception meeting. They were informed that the program would begin with the baseline data collection which doubled as a diagnostic, and consist of virtual and in-situ coaching. A baseline survey of 452 eligible enterprises and their employees was carried out in April and May 2021, with the remaining MSMEs refusing to participate in the survey, being unresponsive or unavailable over the duration of six weeks. Out of the MSMEs who responded to the baseline survey, 250 firms were randomly assigned to the treatment group receiving individual consulting in blocks formed by the administrative region, size in terms of the number of employees, the share of female employees, and annual revenue. Both treatment and control group received access to an online platform with courses on general management topics.

For the individual consulting, five Ivorian consulting firms that had won a local tender to deliver the program were each randomly assigned 50 firms, after blocking by geographic region and enterprise size. The consultants were tasked with the following program activities:

1) Drawing up a report including an analysis of the main weaknesses and key recommendations for each enterprise (with an emphasis on the areas of financial management and HR management);
2) Validating the contents of the report with the firm’s main manager and providing the necessary tools to implement the recommendations;
3) Validating the report and tools with the Agence CI PME;
4) Supporting the implementation of the recommendations;
5) Reporting regularly on the implementation of the recommendations.

Before contacting enterprises, the consultants were provided with the baseline data as well as a portrait of each enterprise including an analysis of financial management and HR management practices as a basis for their reports. They were encouraged to collect additional information from the firms where necessary.

During the implementation of the program, monitoring data is provided regularly by the consultants. Such data covers the number of consultant visits, weaknesses identified in the firm’s management, recommendations given, and tools provided by the consultants, as well as regular updates on the implementation of recommended changes. Shortly after the end of the program, the Agence CI PME will implement a brief follow-up survey with the enterprises of the treatment group, which will serve as a verification check for the information given by the consultants and provide information on satisfaction with and perceived usefulness of the intervention.

Approximately six and twelve months after the end of the benefits period, respectively, we will conduct follow-up interviews with treatment and control group enterprises as well as their employees. In addition and where possible, we will use administrative data from public service providers, for example the social security provider, to complement our analyses.

Design details

Randomization method
The random assignment is done by PIs with a replicable procedure using statistical software.
Randomization unit
For the assignment of the program, the unit of randomization is the firm.
Clusters
452 enterprises and approximately 2,090 employees.
Observations
452 enterprises and approximately 2,090 employees.
Arms
The treatment group consists of 250 enterprises, the control group consists of 202 enterprises.
Primary outcomes
Our evaluation considers outcomes both at the enterprise and at the employee level. At the firm level, important outcomes are (i) employment, measured both in terms of the number of jobs and hours worked, as well as in terms of staff turnover and workforce composition, (ii) employment security and quality, e.g. the share of employees with a written contract or registered for social security, as well as the provision of training opportunities and benefits, (iii) other HR management practices, (iv) metrics of firm performance, such as revenue and profit, (v) capital and labor productivity, (vi) access to finance and financial constraints, (vii) financial management practices. At the individual level, outcomes are (i) employment, e.g. in terms of hours worked and job mobility/retention as well as diversification of income sources, (ii) employment quality in terms of a variety of outcomes such as earnings, having a written contract, job satisfaction, or training opportunities, and (iii) mobility, e.g. in terms of individuals’ interest in and planning for relocating within Côte d’Ivoire or migrating internationally.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords