Self-managed teams in the context of community care for the elderly : effect on working conditions and quality of care.

How to cite

Toulemon, Lea; Toulemon, Léa; Roy, Delphine; Breda, Thomas; Stricot, Maëlle; Rain, Audrey. 2021. "Self-managed teams in the context of community care for the elderly : effect on working conditions and quality of care.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008487. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8487-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Lea Toulemon* , Léa Toulemon , Delphine Roy , Thomas Breda , Maëlle Stricot , Audrey Rain

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008487
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8487-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2021-11-04 – 2024-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I1, J81
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8487

Abstract

The Buurzorg healthcare organisation, created by Jos de Blok in 2006 with a dozen professionals, currently includes 10.000 employees. This success encouraged the adoption of this organisational model by other organizations, in France and around the world. By giving employees more autonomy to organize their schedule and the care plan of the patient, this model of self-managed teams is supposed to empower employees. The employees would be more motivated and satisfied, and the quality of their work would be improved for the beneficiaries.

In France, the long-term care sector is growing and suffering: the working conditions are difficult while wages and career prospects are low. The implementation of the "autonomous teams" model, inspired by Buurtzorg's principles, seems a promising avenue to limit job dissatisfaction and turnover, but the management of schedules and care plans implies developing new skills, and a high level of investment at work. A careful impact evaluation would ensure that this organisational model indeed improves workers satisfaction and the care received by beneficiaries.

This project aims at evaluating the effects of the new working organisation called autonomous teams on the employees (absenteeism, turnover, psychosocial risks, job satisfaction) and on the beneficiaries (hospitalizations, deaths, medication, nursing home entry). It aims at informing public policies from the public health and the health at work standpoints.

To ensure that long-term care organisations, teams and employees that undergo the change in organisations are comparable to those that do not, we implement a randomized controlled trial. This means randomly choosing, among the teams of employees that are willing to adopt the new model, the ones that will actually change their work organisation. The causal impact of the program will be measured by comparing the treated and control employees and care beneficiaries.

Intervention

Home care services choose to participate in the experiment, then they choose teams that could switch to the self-managed team model. Among those teams, we randomly pick the teams which will implement the new model. The teams selected to participate to the experiment that do not switch to the new model make up the control group and keep their standard working organisation.

All home care services under investigation take care of dependent elderly persons : those who are followed by treated teams will benefit from their new working organisation. The dependent elderly persons who are cared for by the control group teams will benefit from the standard working organisation.

Experimental design

We implement a random draw among teams that have been designated to participate to the experiment in each of the home care service provider participating to the experiment. The randomization is therefore stratified by home care service provider. Within each of them, denote N the number of teams that is pre-selected to take part in the experiment. We select randomly about N/2 teams. The rounding is adjusted at each draw in order to keep an equal overall number of treated and control teams in the experiment. This adjustment exploits the fact that not all home care service provider enters the experiment at the same time. The total number of participating home care service is not pre-specified and will depend on our ability to recruit new participants while the experiment starts among the first of these service providers.

Treated and control teams keep taking care of the same dependent or disabled persons as before.

When the random draw is realized at the individual level, we similarly pick half of the individuals in each health care provider to be subject to the self-managed model. We then reconstruct new teams among workers assigned to the treatment.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
The randomization unit is the working team (typically comprising 8 to 12 individuals); it can be the individual if possible for the home care services structure.
Clusters
About 38 home care service providers. More if possible. The experiments starts while some home care providers have not been recruited yet. We include systematically in the experiment all providers that we approach and accept to apply our experimental design pre-specified in a written document.
Observations
152 teams.
Arms
76 treated teams and 76 teams in the control group.
Primary outcomes
1. Employees' job quality 2. Beneficiaries' health and satisfication with the service provided
Secondary outcomes
See above (no distinction made between primary and seconday outcomes)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords