Nudging towards micro-savings: A step-wedge experiment on LPG adoption in rural Tanzania

How to cite

Gill-Wiehl, Annelise; Ray, Isha; Kammen, Daniel; Hubbard, Alan; Levine, David. 2022. "Nudging towards micro-savings: A step-wedge experiment on LPG adoption in rural Tanzania." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008465. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8465-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Annelise Gill-Wiehl* , Isha Ray , Daniel Kammen , Alan Hubbard , David Levine

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008465
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8465-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-01-05 – 2023-06-30
Countries
Tanzania, United Republic of (Mara)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8465

Abstract

Sustainable Development Goal 7 calls for “access to affordable, reliable, sustainable, and modern energy for all”. Affordability is one of the largest barriers to providing this access to the 2.6 billion people relying on solid, smoky fuels. This work evaluates the impact of a micro-savings intervention aimed at achieving higher rates of consistent use of clean fuel, in this case, liquified petroleum gas (LPG). We propose to conduct a step-wedge randomized control trial (SW-RCT) in rural Tanzania to evaluate household consumption of liquified petroleum gas before and after enrollment in a savings bank program. We will respectively address the quantitative treatment effect estimates and the qualitative observation and interview results of this SW-RCT.

Intervention

Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 7 calls for the adoption and continued use of clean-burning stoves by the 2.6 billion people relying on solid, smoky fuels. Universal access to clean cooking fuel would help prevent up to 2.3 million annual untimely deaths that are attributed to household air pollution (HAP) —a toll that disproportionately affects women and children—and reduce carbon emissions. However, to date, the clean cooking literature has found low rates of efficient stove adoption. Barriers include: affordability (initial stove and recurring fuel costs), unreliable supply, social acceptability, household education levels, household socio-economic and demographic characteristics, and low total perceived benefits. In Tanzania, the Energy and Water Utilities Regulatory Authority is promoting Liquified Petroleum Gas (LPG), but only 4.4% of the population is using LPG, and even fewer are using it consistently. To meet SDG7, the global community must act quickly to overcome barriers to LPG adoption and sustained use.
In 2018, Gill-Wiehl piloted the use of a locally-trained Community Technology Worker (CTW) to support and encourage behavior change to switch from dirty fuels to LPG in rural Tanzania. That pilot resulted in high rates of LPG adoption (~80%); however, liquidity constraints remained a major barrier to regular refilling. The households in the pilot expressed a desire and need for a place to save for their monthly refill. Additionally, affordability issues and gender norms lead to a few-day gap between clean fuel refills, and thus further unclean fuel use. Microcredit is the most commonly cited instrument to address issues of affordability; however, repaying is often burdensome, especially for women, who need a safe place to save, but do not necessarily need to borrow. To address affordability concerns, the literature has focused mainly on the upfront cost of the LPG stove, not on saving for the recurring fuel costs or reducing the refill gap. The challenge to refill a clean stove (on time) is an opportunity to promote small savings and to increase consistent use. This research asks: How does a microsaving option for the refill fuel cost coupled with local outreach affect LPG adoption? This question addresses the key gap between purchasing an LPG stove (with or without credit) and purchasing the refills that enable regular LPG use.
We propose to conduct a year long step-wedge randomized control trial (SW-RCT) in order to evaluate, understand, and compare rates of adoption of LPG of households with the CTW model before and after enrollment in a savings bank. We will combine quantitative and qualitative methods to analyze (i) the adoption, consistent use, and refilling patterns of households before and after their participation in a savings bank and (ii) behavioral aspects at the individual, communal, and market level that affect LPG adoption. The successful completion of this research will result in the Intent to Treat (ITT) Effects and the observed treatment effects of the savings bank on stove adoption metrics described in detail below, and the revelation of qualitative behaviors and themes that drive LPG adoption.

Experimental design

The SW-RCT is a cross over design in which households (N=~500) will cross over from control to intervention with a year-long follow-up period to allow consistent use to be established. Each household will receive two LPG stove and burner sets, along with education from their CTW and weekly follow up visits. The CTW’s role is to provide education and maintenance support, but also to nudge the household weekly to save money towards their refill. The treatment in this study is the option to deposit money in a micro-savings program for their LPG refill. We piloted whether the microsavings program should be through mobile money or a physical lockbox. Households in Shirati preferred the lockbox to a mobile money program. Households will have the option to have the CTW keep the key or care for it themselves. The micro-savings program mirrors how households are accustomed to purchasing firewood or charcoal—small sums on a day-to-day basis. There is no other micro-savings program for cooking fuel in Shirati available to the households while in the control (before they cross over) and access to formal financial services is limited, expensive, and inconvenient.

Design details

Randomization method
We will randomize both the order in which the households receive the intervention and the households who will participate in the program. We will utilize a spatial sampling method to randomly select households from the villages. Unfortunately, the 2012 Tanzanian Census was not updated from the 2002 Census, and therefore, is not reliable for the sampling strategy. We will utilize Google Maps and Python to randomly place ~500 points within Shirati and the closest household will be invited to participate.
Randomization unit
Our unit of randomization is the household.
Clusters
~500 Households (510 enrolled to account for attrition, refusal, etc.)
Observations
~500 Households (510 enrolled to account for attrition, refusal, etc.)
Arms
~500 control households that will cross over into treatment (510 enrolled to account for attrition, refusal, etc.)
Primary outcomes
Our key outcome variables relate directly to our four hypotheses: 1) Participating in a savings bank will lead to more purchased LPG refills over the time period. 2) Participating in a savings bank will lead to shorter lag times between cylinder refills. 3) Participating in a savings bank will lead to households using LPG exclusively. 4) Participating in a savings bank will lead to households using less firewood and charcoal Therefore, our outcome variables are 1) the number of LPG refills over the study period, 2) the refill gap (in days) between when the cylinder runs out and is refilled, (3) the percentage of households exclusively using LPG, and (4) the change in the amount of firewood/charcoal used by each household (as compared to the baseline).
Sponsors
Name: D-Prize Location: Oakland, CA, USA Url: https://d-prize.org/winners/profiles/2019/8/5/community-technology-worker-program Name: Lau Graduate Fellowship in Climate Equity Location: Berkeley, CA, USA Url: https://nature.berkeley.edu/lau-graduate-fellowship-climate-equity Name: Center for African Studies, University of California, Berkeley Location: Berkeley, CA, USA Url: https://africa.berkeley.edu/rocca-dissertation-research Name: Google Responsible Supply Chain Location: Mountain View, California Url: https://sustainability.google/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords