Matching new agricultural technology with the demand for innovation of low-income farmers

How to cite

Puerto, Sergio; Gómez, Miguel. 2021. "Matching new agricultural technology with the demand for innovation of low-income farmers." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008452. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8452-2.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sergio Puerto* , Miguel Gómez

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008452
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8452-2.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2021-08-08 – 2023-03-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8452

Abstract

Why are farmers so slow to adopt seemingly profitable new technologies? A vast literature has examined this question, focusing mainly on demand-side factors affecting farmers. An under-appreciated aspect of this problem is that new technologies are not typically tailored to the needs of many of the world’s small-scale farmers. Although public research centers are the main supplier of agricultural technology in most low-income countries, they often lack resources and mechanisms to match new technologies with farmers’ demand for innovation. This constraint can limit the ability of agricultural R&D to prioritize and target new technology. Yet, we know little about the impact on technological change when the choices of resource-constrained agricultural researchers do not reflect the preferences of the farmers who must ultimately take up the new technologies. We propose a field experiment to estimate the effect of imperfect targeting on farmers’ take-up of improved beans varieties in Costa Rica. Commonly, plant breeding programs release a single new variety per cycle to supply a large and heterogeneous group of farmers. The challenge is that we only observe the varieties that breeders release, not the counterfactual varieties they may have chosen to develop had they been able to better target farmers’ preferences for new varieties. We recreate these counterfactual scenarios in an experiment that relaxes information constraints on breeders to estimate their effect on the adoption decisions of 840 small and medium-scale farmers.

Intervention

Randomized control trial offering a new seed variety for purchase to low- and medium-scale farmers in Costa Rica.

Experimental design

Our experimental design consists of two stages designed to answer four research questions. In the first stage, we will conduct trials with half of the farmers to test the on-farm performance of five new bean varieties. The trials also allow us to capture farmers’ revealed preferences for these seeds. Using a blind procedure, each farmer in the trial receives a random set of three varieties to evaluate their performance in several traits. Each farmer in the sample will then be advised about which variety is best for their plot, using the trial results and expert information from crop scientists that mimics their process for making real-world recommendations when a new variety is released. Farmers will also be asked to decide what variety they would like to buy for the next season.

In the second stage, we will test whether imperfect targeting limits the adoption of the new varieties. Our intervention consists of a randomized offer of one of the new varieties to each farmer. First, the benchmark group will be offered for purchase a fixed amount of a new variety of their preference from the set tested in the trials. This group represents an ideal but unrealistic situation in which the supply of new crop varieties matches exactly farmers’ revealed preferences for the new varieties. In other words, each farmer in the benchmark group faces their own synthetic market for seeds. On the other hand, the treatment group will be offered the variety recommended by the breeders, which is the case with many seeds systems in low-income countries, especially for minor crops. The comparison between the treatment and benchmark groups captures the mismatch that arises due to differences between plant breeders’ prediction of the variety that is better for the overall conditions of many farmers versus farmers’ choices. Thus, this design allows us to study realistic farmer-researcher interactions involved in the release and diffusion of new crop varieties.

Design details

Randomization method
Clustered sampling: Clusters were selected based on logistical and research criteria. A total of 7 individuals per cluster were randomly selected. Random samples were constructed using computer software and based on administrative data of the target population.
Randomization unit
-First stage: stratified randomization (village level) -Second stage: individual level randomization
Clusters
120 villages
Observations
800 farmers
Arms
200 farmers per treatment arm
Primary outcomes
1) Adoption take-up rates, 2) Planted area under the adopted variety
Secondary outcomes
3) Farm yield, 4) Input allocations (labor, land, and fertilizer), 5) Yield losses (biotic and abiotic losses in production), and 6) Price per unit sold

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords