The Effects of Child Care Subsidies on Women’s Economic Opportunities in the Slums of Nairobi

How to cite

Clark, Shelley; Kabiru, Caroline. 2015. "The Effects of Child Care Subsidies on Women’s Economic Opportunities in the Slums of Nairobi." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000843. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.843-4.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Shelley Clark* , Caroline Kabiru

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0000843
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.843-4.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2015-09-15 – 2018-08-31
Countries
Kenya (Africa)
JEL codes
J13, J08
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/843

Abstract

In urban informal settlement areas of Nairobi (Kenya), as throughout sub-Saharan Africa (SSA), women’s ability to achieve economic autonomy is often curtailed by their concurrent responsibility to care for young children. In this paper, we present our pre-analysis plan of our randomized experiment to assess the effects of subsidized and improved quality daycare on women’s engagement with the labor force in an informal settlement area of Nairobi. Approximately 1,200 mothers with children aged 1 to 3 will be enrolled in our study. One third of these women will be randomly assigned to receive vouchers for a full year of free child care at local daycare facilities. Another third will be given similar vouchers at daycare facilities where child care providers will receive enhanced early childhood care and education (ECCE) training and materials to improve the quality of services. The remaining third will act as our comparison group. Our analyses will focus on the effects of this intervention on three primary outcomes 1) women’s labor force participation, 2) hours worked, and 3) household income.

Intervention

Interventions: This study will evaluate two interventions, 1) subsidized daycare and 2) subsidized daycare plus quality improvements, using two treatment arms and one comparison group.

Intervention 1: Subsidized Daycare

The costs of formal daycare can be prohibitively costly to mothers with low earning potential, such as women living in the informal settlement areas of Nairobi. Subsidizing daycare could lower this barrier to economic engagement and encourage mothers with young children to enter the labor force or work longer hours, thereby increasing their household’s total income. Such support may be particularly beneficial to disadvantaged women such as single mothers and recent immigrants who are expected to have the least social support in helping with their childcare. Women in this arm of our study will receive a full year of vouchers for free daycare services at selected local facilities. Participating daycares will also receive modest monthly cash transfers to compensate them for the additional monitoring and help them accommodate a possible increase in their number of enrolled pupils.

Intervention 2: Subsidized Daycare at Improve Daycare Facilities

Given the low quality of some daycare centers in the informal settlements, some mothers may be reluctant to place their children in daycares regardless of the costs. To test whether the availability of affordable and high-quality daycares increase women’s engagement with the workforce, we provide quality improvements to half of the daycares we are subsidizing. These quality improvements include the training of all childcare providers in each selected center using an adapted program used by the Aga Khan Foundation, which is based on UNICEF/WHO’s Care for Child Development (C4CD) model, an Early Childhood Development (ECD) intervention. The C4CD intervention provides information and recommendations for cognitive stimulation and social support to young children, through sensitive and responsive caregiver-child interactions. The C4CD package guides health workers, caregivers, counsellors, and parents to build stronger relationships with their children, solve problems in caring for their children, and learn how to be sensitive and respond to the needs of the children. Childcare providers will also receive training on nutrition, child security, toy development, hygiene, sanitation, adequate sleep, and record keeping. The training will be covered in 5 full-days (after 2 days of a needs assessment pre-visit by the master trainers). Refresher training would also be offered half way through the intervention period. Two District Centres for Early Childhood Education (DICECE) officers will also be assigned to Korogocho area to check in and reinforce the learnings with caregivers through daycare visits, and act as the go between our project and the county government. Daycares in the quality arm will also receive material supplies in the form of mattresses, potties, padlocks (to increase security), and materials to build portable hand washing stations, toys, and teaching tools

Experimental design

The randomization process will proceed as follows. During the baseline survey, mothers will be asked whether they are currently sending their child (aged 1 to 3) to a daycare and, if so, to provide the name and location of the daycare. Daycares used by the mothers will then be compiled into a list. Based on our initial daycare inventory survey in Korogocho, we anticipate identifying approximately 45 daycares. Daycares on this list will be randomly assigned to one of the three arms of the study: a comparison arm, a voucher only arm, and a voucher plus quality improvement arm (voucher plus). Thus, we expect to have about 15 daycares in each arm, and we will create a separate list of daycares in each arm. Mothers, whose children are already enrolled in daycare, will be given vouchers for a full year of free services at their current daycare. Mothers, whose children are not currently in daycare, will be randomized into one of the three arms. If mothers are selected for either the voucher or voucher plus arm, they will be given a list of daycares in the arm for which they were selected and informed that they may select anyone of these daycares and be given a year of free services.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer
Randomization unit
For women who are already using daycare, the treatment is clustered at the daycare-level. For women not currently using daycare, randomization occurs at the individual level.
Clusters
45 daycares
Observations
1,200 mothers
Arms
400 mothers/15 daycares in each treatment arm
Primary outcomes
a) Women’s labour force participation, b) Women’s number of hours worked per week, and c) Total household and women's income

Papers from this trial

  1. Clark, Shelley, Caroline Kabiru, Sonia Laszlo, and Stella Muthuri. 2017. “Can Subsidized Early Child Care Promote Women’s Employment?: Evidence from a Slum Settlement in Africa.” GrOW Research Working Paper Series. #5, Institute for the Study of International Development, McGill University, Montreal, Canada. http://grow.research.mcgill.ca/publications/working-papers/gwp-2017-05.pdf

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords