Supporting Pathways Out of Poverty: A Randomized Evaluation of AMP Up Boston

How to cite

Engle, Elizabeth; Katz, Lawrence; Tebes, Jonathan. 2021. "Supporting Pathways Out of Poverty: A Randomized Evaluation of AMP Up Boston." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008429. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8429-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Elizabeth Engle* , Lawrence Katz , Jonathan Tebes

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008429
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8429-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2021-10-27 – 2032-10-27
Countries
United States of America (Massachusetts)
JEL codes
I38, J24, D14
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8429

Abstract

Can Mobility Mentoring – a system of holistic, one-on-one mentorship combined with monetary incentives – help low-income residents achieve economic self-sufficiency? Specifically, we aim to examine the effects of Mobility Mentoring delivered through the AMP Up Boston program on participant economic outcomes (employment, earnings, household income, and financial health), housing stability, receipt of subsidized housing and other public benefits, and (if funding permits us to do follow-up surveys) health and well-being outcomes. With help from the Boston Housing Authority (BHA), Economic Mobility Pathways (EMPath) will recruit participants for the AMP Up Boston program from residents in BHA public housing and recipients of BHA housing vouchers and randomly assign access to the program among interested eligible residents. Treatment group participants will be able to receive three years of Mobility Mentoring Services, while control group participants will receive the services usually available to them in the community. We plan to follow study participants for ten years from random assignment through administrative data, allowing us to see whether recipients of Mobility Mentoring make temporary, short-term gains or sustainable, long-term changes in their economic situation.

Intervention

AMP Up Boston provides personal assistance through Mobility Mentoring, a system of goal setting, incentives, and individualized coaching designed to holistically address the problems participants face. Through regular meetings, mentors assess and track progress along five domains – family life, health, finances, education, and career. Mentors work with families to develop a customized plan to achieve economic independence, broken down into small, manageable steps. This involves setting goals to pay off debt, obtain additional schooling, apply for jobs, access healthcare, and obtain stable housing. Additionally, mentors offer targeted financial incentives to help encourage individuals to save, obtain training towards a new career, or take other steps toward the goals they have set for themselves. The AMP Up Boston program lasts three years.

Experimental design

The study will recruit participants for the AMP Up Boston program from among eligible residents in BHA public housing and recipients of BHA housing vouchers. Since more residents are likely to be interested in Mobility Mentoring than EMPath can serve, we will randomize access to the program among interested eligible residents. This will create two similar groups, one which is offered Mobility Mentoring through AMP Up Boston (the treatment group) and one which is not (the control group). We can then compare outcomes between the two groups to see what difference Mobility Mentoring makes for those who receive the program, on top of the gains they would have made on their own as seen in the control group. AMP Up Boston participants will be able to receive three years of Mobility Mentoring Services. We plan to follow study participants’ outcomes for ten years from random assignment through administrative data, allowing us to see whether recipients of Mobility Mentoring make temporary, short-term gains or sustainable, long-term changes in their economic situation.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer random number generator
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
N/A
Observations
570. We will end recruitment once we have 200 active program participants in the treatment arm, so this number may be smaller or larger depending on the take-up rate of the program among the treatment group. Also, if funding can be attained to hire additional mentors and serve more participants, we will try to increase the sample size to 267 active program participants and increase the treatment and control groups (with a 50 percent treatment randomization rate) to reach this number receiving Mobility Mentoring Services.
Arms
285 treatment participants, 285 control participants. We will end recruitment once we have 200 active program participants in the treatment arm, so this number may be smaller or larger depending on the take-up rate of the program among the treatment group. Also, if funding can be attained to hire additional mentors and serve more participants, we will try to increase the sample size to 267 active program participants and increase the treatment and control groups (with a 50 percent treatment randomization rate) to reach this number receiving Mobility Mentoring Services. Finally, if the take-up rate of services among the treatment group is below 70%, we may continue recruitment until we achieve 80% power to detect the minimum detectable effects noted in our power calculations.
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcome is annual labor earnings (or quarterly earnings, if available).
Secondary outcomes
Our secondary outcomes are: - employment (an indicator for whether an individual is employed) - high-wage employment (an indicator for whether an individual is employed in a high-wage job) - total annual household income - housing stability and housing support (receipt of rent subsidy, amount of rent subsidy, homelessness, neighborhood poverty rate) - personal finance (credit score, overdue debts, delinquencies) from credit bureau data - education and training (completion of high school diploma/GED/HiSET, completion of certification, completion of associate's degree, completion of bachelor's degree, training and employment program participation) - health and well-begin (survey measures of self-assessed physical and mental health if follow-up survey funding available) - public assistance (receipt and amount of SNAP and TANF benefits) Subgroup Analyses We plan to examine heterogeneity of effects on the listed primary and secondary outcomes by: - race - primary language - employment status at start of study
Sponsors
Name: J-PAL North America Url: https://www.povertyactionlab.org/ Name: Michael & Susan Dell Foundation Url: https://www.dell.org/ Name: Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation Url: https://www.gatesfoundation.org/ Name: Blue Meridian Foundation Url: https://www.bluemeridian.org/
Partners
Name: Boston Housing Authority (BHA) Url: https://bostonhousing.org/en/Home.aspx Name: Economic Mobility Pathways (EMPath) Url: https://www.empathways.org/ Name: J-PAL North America Url: https://www.povertyactionlab.org/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords