College Advising at a National Scale: Experimental Evidence from the CollegePoint Initiative
How to cite
Castleman, Ben; Sullivan, Zach; Bettinger, Eric; Lohner, Gaby. 2021. "College Advising at a National Scale: Experimental Evidence from the CollegePoint Initiative." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008379. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8379-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In-person college advising programs generate large improvements in college persistence and success for low-income students but face numerous barriers to scale. Remote advising models offer a promising strategy to address informational and assistance barriers facing the substantial majority of low-income students who do not have access to community-based advising, yet the existing evidence base on the efficacy of remote advising is limited. We present a comprehensive, multi-cohort experimental evaluation of CollegePoint, a national remote college advising program for high-achieving low- and moderate-income students. Students assigned to CollegePoint are modestly more likely (1.3 percentage points) to attend higher-quality institutions. Results from mechanism experiments we conducted within CollegePoint indicate that moderate changes to the program model, such as a longer duration of advising and modest expansions of the pool of students academically eligible to participate, do not lead to larger program effects. We also capitalize on across-cohort variation in whether students were affected by COVID-19 to investigate whether social distancing required by the pandemic increased the value of remote advising. CollegePoint increased attendance at higher-quality institutions by 3.2 percentage points for the COVID-19-affected cohort.
Intervention
CollegePoint is a national remote college advising program that matches high-achieving, low- and moderate-income high school juniors and seniors with college advisors who provide one-on-one support with college exploration and preparation, college, financial aid, and scholarship applications, and college choice. College advisors begin working with students between the spring of their junior year of high school and the fall of their senior year of high school, and conclude advising during the summer after students graduate from high school.
Experimental design
CollegePoint recruited students through the College Board and other partners. Among students who indicated interest in participating and who met the academic (90th percentile or higher of the SAT distribution; 3.5 GPA or higher) and income eligibility criteria (family income of $80,000 or lower), students from the high school classes of 2018, 2019, and 2020 were randomly assigned to receive CollegePoint advising or to a control group that did not receive support from the program.
In addition we conducted two mechanism experiments. In the first mechanism experiment, students were randomly assigned to begin advising during the spring of their junior year or in the fall of their senior year. In the second mechanism experiment, students from a modestly lower segment of the academic distribution (85th - 89th percentile in the SAT distribution) were randomly assigned to CollegePoint advising or to a control group that did not receive support from the program.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.