Individual Decision Making 01

How to cite

Ottoni-Wilhelm, Mark. 2021. "Individual Decision Making 01." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008287. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8287-3.4

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Mark Ottoni-Wilhelm*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008287
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8287-3.4
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2021-09-29 – 2024-11-18
Countries
United States of America (Indiana, Illinois, Michigan, Ohio, Kentucky)
JEL codes
D64, D91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8287

Abstract

This is an investigation of dual motives to give to charity: altruism and warm-glow.

Intervention

There are three sessions to the experiment. Session 2 is the central experiment and is described first.

Session 2: The objective of this experiment is to test the empathy–altruism hypothesis for charitable giving. The giving is to a children’s hospital’s social and emotional support program. The control group reads a simple three-sentence description of the program. One treatment arm reads a fundraising e-mail. The second treatment arm sees a video showing the program in action.

Session 1: The objective of this experiment is to investigate whether three non-substantive aspects of the experimental instructions affect the measures of altruism and warm-glow preferences. If not, great.
If so, we will use the Session 1 results to decide which of the three versions of the experimental instructions we will use.

Session 3: The objective of this experiment is to obtain additional sample size for the measurement of emotional responses to the same treatments we use in Session 2.

Experimental design

Session 2: The experimental design is between-subjects (3 x 1) and in each condition: within-subject (the six decisions).

The participants will be recruited by SSRS (and their partners) and invited to complete a study on “Individual Decision Making”. The inclusion criteria are: (1) resident in the \sout{44} 92 Indiana counties \sout{close to Indianapolis, and not close to another city that has a children’s hospital}, (2) 18 years or older, and (3) an equal number of women and men (to the best of SSRS’s ability to balance gender from the probability panels and the nonprobability panels).

2023-08-16: All participants will complete five real-effort, bibliographic data entry tasks (10 to 15 minutes) to earn their payment (either $52 or $63).

Approximately one-third of the participants will be randomly assigned to each of the three conditions: control, e-mail, and video.

After watching the conditions, all participants fill out the Emotional Response Scale, the Principle of Care state measurement, and the Inclusion of Other in the Self. They then make their six decisions.
Then they answer the Interpersonal Reactivity Index, the Attention-Check question, the Principle of Care dispositional scale, gender, race/ethnicity, the Manipulation-Check questions, the experiment context questions, the questions about familiarity with the children’s hospital, the religion questions, and the political preference question.
At the very end, they decide whether they want a longer-term relationship with the hospital.

Session 1: The experimental design is also between-subjects (3 x 1) and in each condition: within-subject (the six decisions). The participants will be recruited by SSRS and invited to complete a study on “Individual Decision Making”. The inclusion criteria are: (1) a resident of the Indiana-48 perimeter counties, IL, KY, MI, or OH, (2) 18 years or older, and (3) an equal number of women and men (again, to the best of SSRS’s ability to balance gender from the probability panel).

Approximately one-third of the participants will be randomly assigned to each of the three conditions: check nothing, check own payment, and check own payment as well as how much is going to the hospital.

Session 3: The experimental design is also between-subjects (3 x 1), but there is no within-subject variation (participants do not make six donation decisions). The three conditions are the same as in Session 2: control, e-mail, and video.

The participants will be QRS panel members invited to complete a study on “Individual Decision Making”. The inclusion criteria are: (1) resident of IL, KY, MI, or OH, (2) 18 years or older, (3) an equal number of women and men, and (4) an age quota, so that the Qualtrics respondents match (approximately) the US age-sex distribution.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization by computer.
Randomization unit
Individual.
Clusters
No clusters.
Observations
Session 1: N = 270 SSRS participants (in Indiana-48 perimeter counties and IL, KY, MI, OH). Probability-based sample. We concluded Session 1 with N = 87 after the results first indicated that approximately one-half of the participants made decisions at the top-corner, and our Modification 1 did not affect that result. N = 68 were from a probability-based sample, and N = 19 were from a non-probability-based sample (the N = 19 non-prob sample was a Modification 1 idea to determine whether the top-corner problem was specific to the probability-based sample). Session 2: N = 575 to 600 SSRS, Ipsos, \sout{Prodege, QuestMindShare} participants (in Indiana-44+48=92 counties). N = 600 Probability-based sample (SSRS and Ipsos). \sout{N = 240 nonprobability (Prodege and QuestMindShare).} Session 3: N = 897 Qualtrics participants (in IL, KY, MI, OH).
Arms
Session 1: N = \sout{90} Approximately 30 per arm. Session 2: N = 200 Session 3: N = 300
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes are the amounts given to the children’s hospital in the six decisions. From these measures of generosity, altruistic motivation, and egoistic motivation can be constructed. See the Measurement/Analysis. Longer-term effects: At the end of the experiment each participant will be given the option to begin a longer-term relationship with the hospital. The outcomes will be: (1) subscribe to the hospital’s email newsletter, (2) make a $5 one-time donation that is in addition to the amount the participant may have donated from their experimental endowment, or (3) make a monthly $5 donation.
Secondary outcomes
Most of the secondary outcomes were described in AEARCTR-0005478 (“First Session 2: Evaluating Messages”): Empathic State, Distress State, Negative State, Guilt State. Principle of Care State, Inclusion of Other in the Self, Interpersonal Reactivity Index, the Principle of Care disposition, and Attention-Check and Manipulation-Check Questions. In addition, there will be measures of demographics (age, sex, race/ethnicity, Indiana county or state), questions about the context of the experiment, prior knowledge of the hospital, religiosity, political preference (conservative-liberal), and attention/manipulation-check questions. See the Measurement/Analysis plan for details.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords