Co-producing environmental conservation and social equity: Is conditionality in Payments for Ecosystem Services a necessity or impediment?

How to cite

Bauchet, Jonathan; Ma, Zhao; Godoy, Ricardo; Zanotti, Laura; Radel, Claudia. 2021. "Co-producing environmental conservation and social equity: Is conditionality in Payments for Ecosystem Services a necessity or impediment?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008286. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8286-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jonathan Bauchet* , Zhao Ma , Ricardo Godoy , Laura Zanotti , Claudia Radel

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008286
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8286-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2016-09-01 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8286

Abstract

Modern conservation approaches have proved largely ineffective to redress ecosystem degradation at local to global scales. There is a growing interest in market-based conservation as a promising alternative. In particular, payments for ecosystem services (PES) have become increasingly popular, with $66 billion spent globally on watershed-focused PES programs as of 2011. At the core of PES is the assumption that payments made to natural resource managers to produce environmental benefits must be conditional on observable actions or measurable outcomes, which implies that natural resource managers need to be coerced (through monitoring and enforcement) to conserve the environment. However, cultural and political ecologists have long argued that natural resource managers in the Global South possess intrinsic motivations for conservation and that social and cultural systems, political economies, and institutions play important roles in shaping their natural resource decisions. Evidence from geography and other social sciences also suggests that enforcing conditionality in PES is associated with reduced social equity within and across communities. The goal of this research is to determine the role of conditionality in PES in shaping human-environment relations, and the extent to which conditionality can be removed to produce environmental benefits without sacrificing social equity. The research objectives are to: (1) determine the effect of conditionality in PES on environmental conservation outcomes; (2) determine the effect of conditionality in PES on social equity outcomes; and (3) identify mechanisms through which conditional and unconditional payments produce intended and unintended environmental conservation and social equity outcomes. To do so, the team will use a mixed-methods approach that integrates a randomized controlled trial (RCT) with qualitative enquiries to assess conditional versus unconditional PES in 130 rural Bolivian communities.

Intervention

The broad goal of this project is to determine how imposing conditions on program participants in Payments for Ecosystem Services (PES) programs affect program outcomes. This project will help us understand how conditionality in PES programs shapes human-environment relationships at the individual, household, and community scales. We also investigate the extent to which conditions in PES programs can be removed to still produce environmental benefits without increasing social inequalities.

We partner with Fundación Natura Bolivia (FNB), an environmental NGO operating PES programs in Bolivia and other Latin American nations, to examine conditional and unconditional versions of the same PES program that FNB is implementing. PES programs are typically conditional, that is they include monitoring compliance with the commitments taken by program participants in exchange for their receiving an incentive (cash or in-kind) from the program, and sanctions for non-compliance.

Experimental design

Out of a sample of 130 villages in 5 municipalities of the department of Santa Cruz in Bolivia, 65 communities were randomly offered the "normal" (i.e. conditional -- control group) program that FNB offered, and 65 other communities were offered an unconditional version of the program. The unconditional does not include monitoring visits to participants nor sanctions for non-compliance (one visit will be conducted at the end of the project to document compliance, but no sanction will be applied for non-compliance). All other aspects were kept identical (incentive amount and types, offer protocol, contract details, implementing staff, etc.). All land-owning households in a village are eligible to participate in the program; we did not alter participation conditions.

All 130 villages have participated in a previous RCT with FNB. The goal of that RCT was to measure the impacts of the program. It involved randomly offering the program in 65 communities, and keeping 65 communities as a control group where the program was not offered until the end of the RCT. All 130 communities were included in our project, and offered the program. In our RCT, we stratified the randomization by status in the previous RCT so that 1/2 of the communities offered the conditional program had previously been offered the same program and 1/2 of the communities offered the conditional program had never been offered FNB's program before; 1/2 of the communities offered the unconditional program had previously been offered a conditional version of the program and 1/2 of the communities offered the unconditional program had never been offered FNB's program before.

Design details

Randomization method
In office by a computer
Randomization unit
Village
Clusters
130 villages
Observations
900 households
Arms
65 villages control, 65 villages treatment
Primary outcomes
Rates of participation in the program Adoption of conservation behaviors Environmental conservation Characteristics of participants (socio-economic) Gender inequality in participation
Secondary outcomes
Perceived fairness in community
Sponsors
Name: National Science Foundation Url: https://www.nsf.gov Name: Clifford B. Kinley Trust at Purdue University Url: https://www.purdue.edu/research/funding-and-grant-writing/funding/kinley.php
Partners
Name: Fundación Natura Bolivia Partner_type: ngo Url: https://www.naturabolivia.org/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords