Why Do Firms in Low-Income Countries Grow Slowly? An Investigation of Demand-Side Mechanisms
How to cite
Vitali, Anna. 2021. "Why Do Firms in Low-Income Countries Grow Slowly? An Investigation of Demand-Side Mechanisms." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008278. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8278-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Why do firms in low-income countries grow slowly? My research will provide new evidence on demand-side constraints, that is the challenges that firms face in building a customer base. Specifically, I will study how asymmetric information on product quality limits the ability of high-quality firms to attract customers. Accessing new customers may be especially difficult in developing countries due to high search costs that limit quality observability ex-ante (search frictions) and the lack of institutions that can enforce quality standards ex-post (contracting frictions). In this study, I will explore the role of these two frictions in limiting firm access to demand. To do that, I will combine data from a matched firm-customer survey with lab-in-the-field experiments to measure quality dispersion and asymmetric information in a number of small manufacturing sectors in Kampala, Uganda. I will then use this data to estimate a structural model of search with unknown quality and perform counterfactual analysis to quantify the relative importance of search and contracting frictions on firm and employment growth, entry/exit dynamic, and the distribution of quality. The structural approach of this study allows examining the mechanisms through which policies aimed at reducing asymmetric information on product quality may affect market outcomes in a general equilibrium framework. This can be informative of the type of interventions that would be most effective at stimulating firm expansion and the generation of employment in low-income economies.
Intervention
As part of this study, I will conduct a mystery shoppers exercise where I will randomize the characteristics of the customers. Specifically, I will instruct shoppers to use scripts that differ in the stated purpose of the purchase: 50% of the mystery shoppers will say that they are buying a product for private consumption, while 50% will state that they are sampling potential suppliers for their businesses. The type of script that will be recited to firms will be randomized. This will ensure that any difference in the price and the quality of the goods produced by firms receiving the two scripts can be attributed to differences in the script itself. The purpose of the exercise is to study whether firms alter their behaviour as a function of the net present value of a relationship.
Experimental design
The sample for this study comprises of 600 firms in the garment sector operating in Kampala, Uganda. I will employ mystery (i.e. anonymous) shoppers to purchase an identical products from each of these firms, which will then be evaluated by an expert in the sector to obtain accurate measures of quality. Mystery shoppers will be required to follow a precise script for the purchase. I will however produce two different versions of the script. Specifically, the scripts will vary in the stated purpose of the purchase: 50% of the mystery shoppers will say they are buying a product for private consumption ("Final Customer" script), while 50% will state that they are sampling potential suppliers for their businesses ("Business Customer" script). The type of script that will be recited will be randomized at the firm level.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.