Behavioral insights and tax compliance: Experimental evidence from Belgium

How to cite

Neve, Jan-Emmanuel De; Spinnewijn, Johannes. 2015. "Behavioral insights and tax compliance: Experimental evidence from Belgium." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000827. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.827-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jan-Emmanuel De Neve* , Johannes Spinnewijn

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0000827
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.827-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2015-09-01 – 2016-09-01
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/827

Abstract

We aim to study the effect of nudges in reminder letters at two different stages of the tax cycle. In collaboration with the Ministry of Finance of Belgium, we are designing an RCT on Belgian taxpayers that are either late with their tax payment or that have not filed their tax return. For the trial on the late payment reminder we will circulate 8 treatment letters in addition to the current control letter. These treatment letters introduce the following nudges: (1) simplification; (2) social norm; (3) public goods (positively framed); (4) public goods (negatively framed); (5) social norm + public goods; (6) active choice; (7) explicit penalty; and (8) active choice + explicit penalty. For the trial on the late filing reminder the following 3 treatment letters will be circulated in addition to a simplified control letter: (1) social norm; (2) public goods; (3) social norm + public goods. The nudges that we introduce in these reminder letters are grounded in behavioral insights such as loss aversion (positive vs. negatively framed public goods letters), social preferences (social norm letter), and status quo bias (active choice letter). We aim to treat the universe of late tax filers and late taxpayers in Belgium. The last two digits of the national identity number will be used to randomly assign treatment letters across the population. All treatment and control groups have equal size (in terms of number of letters sent out). The outcome variables will include tax payments, timing of payment, and number of filers and we will analyse heterogeneous treatment effects across taxpayers with different characteristics including gender, income, age, job status (employee or self-employed), region, online or paper filing. We also aim to convince the tax administration to send out new letters in a second year in order (1) to further validate the heterogeneous treatment effects using the first-year results to determine the random allocation to treatment and (2) to evaluate the persistence of the treatment effects.

Experimental design

We aim to study the effect of nudges in reminder letters at two different stages of the tax cycle. In collaboration with the Ministry of Finance of Belgium, we are designing an RCT on Belgian taxpayers that are either late with their tax payment or that have not filed their tax return. For the trial on the late payment reminder we will circulate 8 different treatment letters in addition to the current control letter. These treatment letters introduce the following nudges: (1) simplification; (2) social norm; (3) public goods (positively framed); (4) public goods (negatively framed); (5) social norm + public goods; (6) active choice; (7) explicit penalty; and (8) active choice + explicit penalty. For the trial on the late filing reminder the following 3 treatment letters will be circulated in addition to a simplified control letter: (1) social norm; (2) public goods; (3) social norm + public goods.

Design details

Randomization method
The last two digits of the national identity number will be used to randomly assign treatment letters across the population. All treatment and control groups have equal size (in terms of number of letters sent out).
Randomization unit
Individual taxpayers.
Clusters
0
Observations
We aim to treat the universe of late tax filers and late taxpayers in Belgium.
Arms
Our partners at the Ministry of Finance have indicated that the number of observations per treatment arm would be approximately 50,000 individuals.
Primary outcomes
The outcome variables will include tax payments, timing of payment, and number of filers and we will analyse heterogeneous treatment effects across taxpayers with different characteristics including gender, income, age, job status (employee or self-employed), region, online or paper filing. We also aim to convince the tax administration to send out new letters in a second year in order (1) to further validate the heterogeneous treatment effects using the first-year results to determine the random allocation to treatment and (2) to evaluate the persistence of the treatment effects.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords