Test of Consequence Information on Insurance Choices

How to cite

Sydnor, Justin; Samek, Anya. 2021. "Test of Consequence Information on Insurance Choices." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008229. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8229-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Justin Sydnor* , Anya Samek

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008229
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8229-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2016-01-01 – 2017-12-31
Countries
United States of America ()
Secondary IDs
AsPredicted.org Pre-registration Plan 5372
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8229

Abstract

This study investigates the impact of "consequence graphs" on decisions about insurance plans. Participants in our experiments are presented with menus of health insurance options and randomized into different information treatments. In the baseline treatment, participants see "feature-based" information about options, which describe contract features such as premiums, deductibles, and copays. In our primary experimental treatment, participants either or in addition see a "consequence graph", which is a visual representation of the distribution of total financial consequences the individual could expect to have with a give plan. In some of our trials there is a third experimentally assigned treatment condition which combines feature-based information with an expected-spending projection (i.e., projected average) but not the full distribution from the consequence graph. For some of the menus there are dominant options and our primary outcome metric is the share choosing the dominant option under different information displays. In some menus there is no dominant option and we instead investigate simply whether the information treatments lead to different distributions of choices.

Experimental design

This study was conducted with two separate but related experiments.

Experiment 1:
Was conducted at the BRITE Lab at the University of Wisconsin, Madison recruiting a largely university student population.
Subjects choose a preferred health insurance plan in each of 4 menus of options. This set of choices was repeated twice, once under each of our two information treatments, with the order randomized. This randomization allows us to conduct both between-subjects comparisons, by comparing the decisions made under the first information treatment assignment, and within subject analysis comparing across the two sets of decisions.
They were incentivized for their choice by having one of their decisions randomly selected for payment. Payment was based on both a random draw of possible medical bills and the health plan the individual selected.
There were two information treatments: a) feature-based menu (control) and b) consequence-graph display (treatment).
Participants also completed an incentivized question testing their ability to do an insurance calculation and an Eckle-Grossman risk-aversion elicitation.

Experiment 2:
The second experiment was a hypothetical-choice survey experiment conducted with the Understanding America Study panel. This portion of the experiment was pre-registered at AsPredicted.org under pre-registration plan #5372, which can be accessed at https://aspredicted.org/blind.php?x=m9ni37
For this study subjects answered a few questions about their health risks that allowed us to place them into one of 50 health-risk groups. We then randomly assigned subjects to one of three information-treatment groups: a) feature-based table display only (control), b) feature-based table plus consequence graph (primary treatment), c) feature-based table plus expected-spending projection (secondary treatment).
Subjects made choices between a lower-deductible and higher-deductible health plan option in 10 separate menus (i.e., pairs) of options.

Design details

Randomization method
Computerized randomization within the survey/online experiment software.
Randomization unit
Individual level
Clusters
201 individuals (lab experiment) + 692 individuals (UAS survey) = 893 individuals
Observations
201 individuals (lab experiment) + 692 individuals (UAS survey) = 893 individuals
Arms
Lab study: 110 received feature-table for their first display and 91 received the graphical display for their first display. UAS study: 246 Received the feature-table only, 225 received the feature table plus consequence graph, 221 received the feature table plus expected spending projection.
Primary outcomes
Choice of dominated health insurance option Choice of high deductible vs. low deductible health insurance option

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords