Whether to Apply: Fall 2021 Follow-up
How to cite
Coffman, Katherine; Collis, Manuela. 2021. "Whether to Apply: Fall 2021 Follow-up." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008223. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8223-2.2
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In this project, we study the decisions of candidates about whether to apply for different opportunities. We aim to tackle the question of whether there are gender differences in how job-seekers perceive their own qualifications for different opportunities, and how this impacts their decision about whether or not to apply. In addition, we ask whether whether reducing ambiguity around required qualifications for a given opportunity reduces the gender gap in willingness to apply among qualified candidates.
The first experiment we ran for this project was a field experiment on the online labor market platform, UpWork. Serving as a potential employer, we created job opportunities to which participants could apply. In our baseline condition, we found that qualified women were significantly less likely to apply to our more demanding and more lucrative job opportunity than equally qualified men. Our treatment conditions tested a simple policy intervention: we provided more clarity on what “the bar” was in terms of desired qualifications. We found that the gender gap in in application rates among qualified candidates was reduced when the desired qualifications for the opportunity were less ambiguous.
The study we are pre-registering is a follow-up to that study. In particular, we are looking to replicate the results from the UpWork experiment, using a very similar paradigm, but in a new population (Prolific Workers). In addition to replicating our main results, we are adding additional questions aimed at uncovering the mechanisms underlying our results.
Intervention
We will have participants build a "resume" for a job opportunity by completing a screening task. Then, we will present them with the opportunity to apply to either an expert-level job or a more basic job.
Across subject, we vary the language used to describe the required qualifications for the expert-level job. In particular, the control treatment contains a large degree of ambiguity about what "the bar" is for being good enough to be qualified for the expert-level job. Our two treatments reduce this ambiguity by providing clearer, more specific, objective information on what the required qualification is in terms of the screening task.
Experimental design
We will have participants build a "resume" for a job opportunity by completing a screening task. Then, we will present them with the opportunity to apply to either an expert-level job or a more basic job.
Across subject, we vary the language used to describe the required qualifications for the expert-level job. In particular, the control treatment contains a large degree of ambiguity about what "the bar" is for being good enough to be qualified for the expert-level job. Our two treatments reduce this ambiguity by providing clearer, more specific, objective information on what the required qualification is in terms of the screening task.
Design details
Materials
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.