Relational contracting, health externalities, and labor supply in Bangladeshi apparel factories
How to cite
Heath, Rachel; Boudreau, Laura. 2021. "Relational contracting, health externalities, and labor supply in Bangladeshi apparel factories." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008220. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8220-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Manufacturing can provide high-paying jobs for workers in low-income countries, but health issues or caretaking often drive workers (especially women) out of the labor force. Paid sick leave can prevent the spread of disease and keep workers in the workforce, but workers often fear retribution for taking sick leave. We are conducting a stratified, cluster-randomized experiment in collaboration with a large garment manufacturing firm in Bangladesh. All workers receive a phone survey in which they are reminded that their responses will be kept private; treated workers will receive an additional message over the phone: treatment (1) provides a message that the firm cares about their health, (2) provides treatment 1 + a message that respondents are entitled to sick leave and (3) provides treatment 2 + information about recourses if a request for sick leave is denied.
We will estimate the effects of treatment on workers’ reported health (mental and physical), job satisfaction, and absenteeism. Reported health and job satisfaction will be asked after the health messaging in the phone survey. We will also conduct a follow-up survey 2 to 3 weeks after the initial survey, which will provide the information on absenteeism. We will also re-measure health and job satisfaction to assess whether any changes in these outcomes are persistent.
Intervention
Treatment (1) provides a message that the firm cares about their health, (2) provides treatment 1 + a message that respondents are entitled to sick leave and (3) provides treatment 2 + information about recourses if a request for sick leave is denied.
Experimental design
We conduct a survey experiment with workers at two of the apparel manufacturer's factories, which together employ over 8,700 people. First, we conduct a stratified random selection of workers to participate in the survey experiment. Using the entire list of employees in the two factories, we sample workers from four types of production teams. Among these teams, we chose teams with a sufficient large number of workers to accommodate this survey and a separate survey that we are running for a different project (approximately above 15). We are left with 112 eligible teams and a total of 5,948 eligible workers, out of a workforce of 8,727 people, including 1,000 managers and administrative staff members.
We next stratify workers on eligible teams by their sex, which we identify based on name (male, female, uncertain). We are able to categorize names as male or female for 5,929 out of 5,948 eligible workers. In some cases, there are teams with very small numbers of one group; in this case, we aggregate these workers to the smallest level that yields a sufficiently large groups size (e.g., production section-floor).
We conduct this RCT in coordination with another survey experiment that we are running with the apparel manufacturer (RCT ID: AEARCTR-0007103). Consequently, we randomly sample workers from strata as follows:
1. For workers in the sewing section, for sewing line & female strata, randomly select 11 workers per stratum. For sewing line & male strata in the sewing section, which are smaller, randomly select men in proportion to the strata size. This produced an initial target sample of 574 workers.
2. The remaining 5,374 workers were eligible to be recruited for the other survey experiment, AEARCTR-0007103. For this survey experiment, within strata, the research team randomly selected workers as target participants. We randomly ordered the remaining workers in each stratum so that workers who declined to participate could be replaced. We conducted the second survey experiment, for which we recruited or attempted to recruit 3,638 workers. This left 1,736 eligible workers from the list of 5,374 workers who had not been recruited or attempted to be recruited for AEARCTR-0007103.
3. To arrive at the final target sample for this survey experiment, we appended the list of 574 workers and the list of 1,736 workers, for a maximum total sample size of 2,310. Given our successful recruitment rate of 62% in AEARCTR-0007103, we anticipate achieving a realized sample size of around 1,432.
We randomly assign workers to treatment arms in Stata. We randomly assign workers to each treatment arm with equal probability. To address misfits across strata, we use the randtreat package by Carril (2017). We conducted 10 randomizations and selected the one that performed best in terms of balance on two covariates available to the research team (tenure and skill group).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.