Understanding gender dynamics: a tutoring intervention.
How to cite
Llanes, Salome Aguilar; Bueno, Bernardo García Bulle; Cota, Sebastián Guevara. 2021. "Understanding gender dynamics: a tutoring intervention.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008190. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8190-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The learning crisis caused by the covid-19 pandemic is unprecedented. As governments seek to address the learning loss, so far, we know tutoring has been a widely proposed solution because it has proven to have a big positive effect on learning. We propose an RCT which can contribute to the literature of tutoring by eliciting whether different group structures modify how teachers’ stereotypes affect students. This will constitute a step into disentangling the mechanism and generating policy that curbs this effect. Our design will also find effects of students sharing the gender with each other, as well as other covariates important in the Mexican context. Additionally, by using machine learning techniques to analyze the recordings of the tutoring sessions we can begin to disentangle how gender dynamics shape the motivation of students as well as some of the determinants of learning in the classroom.
Intervention
We will work with primary 3rd, 4th and 6th and middle school 1st grade students to allow us to see heterogeneous effects by age. We will choose 300 schools, 200 in Baja California and 100 in Durango. Randomization will be at the student level as we are not concerned of spillover effects, students that participated last semester in the RCT met with their teacher on average less than 5 hours per week through google meets. We will do a stratified randomization caring about the grade of students. We will determine whether tutors have a traditional view of gender roles using the test implemented by (Alan et al 2018), which additionally measures extrinsic vs intrinsic motivation, modern vs traditional teaching, and warm vs distanced teaching to understand whether biased teachers affect kids decisions and performance in the direction of the bias.
We will recruit tutors, volunteers of universities and normal schools seeking to meet their social service requirements of 480 hours to graduate. This same recruitment strategy was successfully implemented by our team in a past tutoring RCT. We will assign the tutors into WhatsApp groups of 5 kids that will meet 2 times a week. All tutors will receive an initial training on how to teach math, a psychopedagogy training, a training on how to handle difficult situations in case they find out of cases of abuse in the family of children and a training session on how to talk about sickness and death with children (because in past tutoring programs during the pandemic the topic has challenged tutors). Tutors will be given the list of subjects sorted in level of difficulty. They will be given the scores in the baseline evaluation of their students and be instructed to start working on the easiest material according to the list that any of their students does not master. After the initial training sessions, all tutors will receive a weekly training in math content, and we will provide office hours on zoom where they can log in to solve their math questions. Additionally, we will create Whatsapp groups (of around 50 tutors of the same treatment) that tutors can use to communicate among each other and share tips and questions. There will be two different ways to structure the groups, and on each kids will receive either a tutor with high stereotypes or low stereotypes. We will randomize children into having mixed gender groups or same gender groups. And then into having a tutor with traditional or non traditional gender beliefs.
Experimental design
We will randomize students into mixed gender or same gender groups,then we will randomize these groups into receiving a tutor with strong or weak traditional gender beliefs.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.