Biased Beliefs about Immigration, Economic Concerns, and Information Provision: The Role of Cultural Distance

How to cite

Bareinz, Patrick; Uebelmesser, Silke. 2021. "Biased Beliefs about Immigration, Economic Concerns, and Information Provision: The Role of Cultural Distance." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008166. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8166-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Patrick Bareinz* , Silke Uebelmesser

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008166
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8166-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2021-09-08 – 2021-09-24
Countries
Germany ()
JEL codes
C90, D83, F22, H20, J15
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8166

Abstract

We investigate whether individual perceptions of the origin of immigrants are linked to economic concerns about immigration in the host society. In our experiment, participants are randomly assigned to one of three experimental groups: two treatment arms and a passive control group. While respondents in the first treatment arm are only subject to belief elicitation employed as a priming device, respondents in the second treatment arm are exposed to factual information about the overall share of immigrants in their society as well as the share of immigrants stemming from European countries. Conversely, the passive control group is neither exposed to factual information nor the priming device. We aim to analyze whether information provision and/or the priming treatment translate into economic concerns about immigration, immigration policy preferences and preferences for redistribution.

Intervention

Participants are randomly assigned to one of three experimental groups: two treatment arms and a passive control group. Specifically, the first treatment consists of a priming device, in which respondents are only subject to belief elicitation about their prior beliefs about the overall share of immigrants as well as the share of immigrants from European countries in Germany, but not exposed to the respective factual information. In contrast, after their prior beliefs have been elicited, respondents in the second treatment arm receive factual information about the overall share of immigrants as well as the share of immigrants stemming from European countries in Germany. Finally, the passive control group is neither exposed to factual information nor the priming device prior to measurement of outcomes. We then aim to examine whether information provision and/or the priming treatment translate into economic concerns about immigration, immigration policy preferences and preferences for redistribution.

Experimental design

Our experimental design consists of four stages. In the first stage, we elicit respondents' prior beliefs about the overall share of immigrants as well as the share of immigrants stemming from European countries in Germany for those individuals allocated to either treatment arm I or treatment arm II. For the passive control group, belief elicitation is conducted after the measurement of outcomes.

In the second stage, random subsets of respondents are either provided with factual information about the overall share of immigrants and the share of immigrants stemming from European countries in Germany, or exposed to belief elicitation employed as a priming device related to perceived aggregate cultural distance to the immigrant population:
- Treatment arm I: is only exposed to belief elicitation about the overall share of immigrants and the share of immigrants from European countries in Germany, constituting a priming device
- Treatment arm II: receives factual information about the overall share of immigrants (representing the size of the immigrant population) and the share of immigrants from European countries in Germany (representing aggregate cultural distance to the immigrant population), after being exposed to belief elicitation
- Control group (passive): does not receive any information and is only exposed to belief elicitation after the measurement of outcomes

In the third stage, respondents are asked literature-based survey measures of our outcome variables: welfare state and labor market concerns about immigration (i.e. economic concerns about immigration), immigration policy preferences, and preferences for redistribution.

In the fourth stage, we elicit respondents' posterior beliefs about the overall share of immigrants and the share of immigrants from European countries in Germany to evaluate belief updating of individuals.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by a computer
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
No clustering
Observations
3000 individuals
Arms
Approximately 1000 individuals for each experimental group
Primary outcomes
Welfare state concerns about immigration Labor market concerns about immigration Immigration policy preferences Preferences for redistribution
Secondary outcomes
Assessement of advantages and disadvantages of immigration

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords