Valuation uncertainty: explaining the WTA-WTP gap and their lack of correlation

How to cite

Arts, Sara; Qiu, Jianying; Zhong, Songfa. 2021. "Valuation uncertainty: explaining the WTA-WTP gap and their lack of correlation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008163. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8163-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sara Arts* , Jianying Qiu , Songfa Zhong

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008163
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8163-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2021-09-06 – 2021-09-29
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8163

Abstract

Putting an exact value on assets is often difficult since it involves a complicated process of trading off different attributes. This difficulty can lead to valuation uncertainty; people consider a range of possible values for an asset instead of one exact value. Valuation uncertainty has important scientific, practical, and societal implications. It is, however, difficult to measure. Using a representative sample of a Dutch household panel, we propose a novel, incentivized measure of a valuation uncertainty interval in which individuals have valuation difficulty. In this measure subjects are allowed to randomize between options when they are not fully confident about their preference. We then use valuation uncertainty to organize a number of seemingly independent anomalies, in particular the WTA-WTP gap and the lack of correlation between the two. Furthermore, we link valuation uncertainty to individual traits and life outcomes.

Experimental design

The experiment consists of five treatments, which allow for testing the effect of the experimental setup. The main treatment will be described here. The difference between the treatments is described below in the clustering description.

Subjects face questions on a simple lottery (50% chance of gaining 900 points and 50% chance of gaining 100 points), which is similar to the lottery used in Chapman et al. (2019), and a complex lottery (20% chance of gaining 975 points, a 30% change of gaining 850 points, a 30% chance of gaining 150 points, and a 20% chance of gaining 25 points). As a control subjects are also asked to answer the question for a 'sure' lottery (100% chance of gaining 500 points).

Subjects go through 3 main sections. First of all, the valuation uncertainty elicitation. The method is based on a standard multiple price list (MPL), in which subjects make a choice between a lottery and a sequence of certain amounts (Holt & Laury, 2002). We extend the method by introducing a third option: the option to receive the lottery or the certain amount randomly. The sure amounts for which subjects choose the option of random assignment define valuation uncertainty interval. The lower bound of the interval is defined by the maximum certain amount at which subjects choose the lottery only, and the upper bound is defined by the minimum certain amount at which subjects choose the certain amount only. These two bounds can serve as “the extremes that define an incomplete preference relation, connecting with the existing approach to modelling the endowment effect that does not rely on loss aversion” (Chapman et al., 2019, p. 37).
Since going through the whole list is tedious, we facilitate subjects’ decision making by asking them to indicate only their switching points from the lottery to the random assignment, and from the random assignment to the certain amount, their preferred choices will be automatically be filled in.
The second and third sections of the experiment will elicit the subjects' Willingness To Accept and Willingness To Pay for each lottery according to the standard approach (Chapman et al., 2019). In these measures subjects will again face a MPL, but this time with the traditional two options. The questions are framed as selling (WTA) and buying (WTP) the lottery for a certain amount. Again, subjects only need to select their switching point, and the table will fill automatically. Finally, in between the different sections subjects will be asked to answer some questions about their cognitive ability (IQ questions), and the desirability of control scale (Burger & Cooper, 1979; Gebhardt & Brosschot, 2002).

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done by a computer when the survey is distributed.
Randomization unit
Subjects are randomly assigned to one of the treatments described below. Within these treatments we randomize between the order of the sections [WTA-WTP-VU, WTP-WTA-VU, VU-WTA-WTP, VU-WTP-WTA] the order of the lotteries [simple-complex OR complex-simple], the order of the values in the MPL [ascending OR descending]. In the single question treatment the order of the sections is fixed (VU-Neutral frame) and only the order of the lotteries and the order of the values in the MPL are randomized.
Clusters
We have 5 different treatments with slightly different methods of elicitating valuation uncertainty. 1. Main treatment (as described above) 2. Cost treatment (there is a small cost for choosing the lottery or the sure amount of points). 3. Benefit treatment (there is a small benefit for choosing the lottery or the sure amount of points). 4. Reduced lottery treatment (instead of 'letting the computer decide' the valuation uncertainty option is described as a reduced lottery of 50% chance of getting the lottery). 5. Single question treatment (instead of a multiple price list with 2 switching points, subjects make a single decision per screen between the lottery, letting the computer decide, or the sure amount of points; instead of the WTA and WTP questions subject select a switching point for both lotteries in a neutral frame).
Observations
2400 subjects
Arms
Depending on response rate, but we are aiming for: 1. Main treatment: N = 1200 2. Cost treatment: N = 200 3. Benefit treatment: N = 200 4. Reduced lottery treatment: N = 200 5. Single question treatment: N = 600
Primary outcomes
- Simple lottery: -- Willingness to Accept -- Willingness to Pay -- Valuation Uncertainty interval - Complex lottery -- Willingness to Accept -- Willingness to Pay -- Valuation Uncertainty interval
Secondary outcomes
- Cognitive ability - Desire for control - Demographic and real-life outcome variables

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords