The impact of subsidized transit passes on health and well-being for people with low incomes

How to cite

Chapkis, Connor; Phillips, David; Cihak, Carrie; Chaiyachati, Krisda; Freedman, Matt. 2021. "The impact of subsidized transit passes on health and well-being for people with low incomes." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008139. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8139-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Connor Chapkis* , David Phillips , Carrie Cihak , Krisda Chaiyachati , Matt Freedman

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008139
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8139-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2021-09-16 – 2026-10-01
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8139

Abstract

In October 2020, King County Metro Transit launched asubsidized annual transit pass program to provide annual transit passes to people with incomes ≤80% of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL) who also receive cash public benefits. The annual pass allows the holder to ride public transit without paying a fare. The project team is evaluating the impact of King County’s annual pass program on health and wellbeing. The team will also look specifically at outcomes by race to understand whether the impacts of the annual pass are racially equitable.

Intervention

The FFPT program is a collaboration between Metro, Sound Transit, and social service agencies who assist with enrollment. As the region’s largest public transit agency, Metro leads the program’s design, implementation, and evaluation of FFPT. Sound Transit, the region’s second largest transit agency, has partnered with Metro on FFPT as a two-year pilot. This allows people who hold the FFPT annual pass to, at no cost, ride on and transfer between all of the two agencies’ services across an extensive regional transit network, primarily Metro’s bus services and Sound Transit’s light rail services.

The enrollment process for FFPT operates through partner social service agencies. The initial roll-out of FFPT is designed to meet capacity constraints of the enrollment agencies, with most people learning about and enrolling in FFPT when they seek other State benefits. Due to COVID-19, most eligible individuals enroll over the phone by calling DSHS or Public Health - Seattle & King County. Eligible individuals can also enroll in person at Public Health offices. The enrollment agencies verify clients' identity, income, and participation in one of the qualifying cash-benefit programs; enter clients’ information into Metro’s FFPT program registry; and provide them with the FFPT pass immediately in-person or through mail. As of mid-March 2021, about 4,000 people (less than 4% of total eligible participants) have been enrolled in FFPT.

The FFPT pass is valid for one year from the date of issuance, regardless of whether the holder’s income or eligibility change. After one year, the pass holder must re-enroll and meet eligibility criteria again to continue to access FFPT. The FFPT pass is visually indistinguishable from the region’s other transit passes (known as ORCA passes) that are commonly used by residents who ride public transit.

Experimental design

How FFPT is being implemented in the program’s first year creates an opportunity to leverage an RCT and difference-in-differences analysis to generate measures of the impacts of FFPT with strong internal and external validity. Our study sample will include three groups of people, all of whom have incomes ≤80% FPL:

Group A: Eligible – Treated
Group B1: Ineligible – Treated
Group B2: Ineligible – Control

In our study sample, Group A is comprised of people in the LIFT registry who are eligible for FFPT and who, after the baseline survey, are immediately connected for enrollment in FFPT.

Group B1 is comprised of people in the LIFT registry who are ineligible for FFPT because they are not enrolled in one of the six State cash benefit programs, who are screened for comparability with Group A, and, after the baseline survey, are randomly assigned to immediate referral for enrollment in FFPT.

Group B2 is the same as Group B1, except that they are randomly assigned to not receive FFPT and remain enrolled in the ORCA LIFT discounted fare
program.

An RCT (B1 vs. B2) allows us to make an internally valid comparison of the impacts of FFPT on people with incomes ≤80% FPL but who are not receiving one of the six State cash benefit programs that make one eligible for FFPT. This directly informs decisions policymakers face about potential expansion of the FFPT eligibility criteria. A difference-in-differences analysis comparing people who are currently eligible for FFPT (Group A) with the control group from the RCT (B2) provides policymakers with relevant information regarding the external validity of the RCT results to people currently receiving FFPT, thereby informing decisions regarding both continuation and expansion of FFPT as well as decisions by other transit agencies in the region about joining FFPT.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer-based randomization to determine placement in group B1 vs. group B2.
Randomization unit
individual
Clusters
3,225 households initially; 2,250 households expected in final survey
Observations
3,225 households initially; 2,250 households expected in final survey
Arms
Group A: Eligible – Treated (1,075 households initially; 750 households expected in final survey) Group B1: Ineligible – Treated (1,075 households initially; 750 households expected in final survey) Group B2: Ineligible – Control (1,075 households initially; 750 households expected in final survey)
Primary outcomes
Number of boardings on public transit at agencies participating in the ORCA LIFT program Total trips by any mode Trips disaggregated by travel mode Payment method Trip purpose Travel time Hours worked per quarter Trips for employment Earnings wage rate being employed job exits job starts job-to-job moves Presence of a credit score credit score credit delinquencies Psychological distress Self-reported physical health
Secondary outcomes
Annual preventive care visit Trips for healthcare purposes Substance use disorder treatment Mental health treatment Prescription fills Vaccinations Hospitalizations Emergency Department Outpatient visits Dual eligibility (Medicare AND Medicaid) Costs of care Enrolled in SNAP Trips for social services Enrolled in different public benefit programs operated by ESA(TANF, etc.) Housing moves having a formal address travel time from home to downtown neighborhood characteristics number of recent days spent unhoused eviction filings homelessness program use Loneliness scale Trips to see family and friends

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords