Split in Probability Weights - Scarcity, Cognitive Load and Tunnelling

How to cite

Pande, Suvarna; Verschoor, Arjan. 2021. "Split in Probability Weights - Scarcity, Cognitive Load and Tunnelling." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008071. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8071-2.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Suvarna Pande* , Arjan Verschoor

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008071
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8071-2.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2021-11-23 – 2022-07-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D91, C93, D81, D87
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8071

Abstract

Understanding the decision-making process is the cornerstone of better policy interventions. Broadly, poverty has focussed on systemic factors, individual factors, environmental pressures or a combination of the three. However, another side of the story remains relatively less understood  – the causal effects of poverty that change the decision-making process itself. A rapidly emerging debate between policymakers brings forth this fourth perspective. Within this framework, the shortfall of resources or poverty changes cognitive systems that ultimately affect the decision. At first glance, low pickup rates of preventative health, medications or high-interest borrowing behaviours of the poor seem actively self–sabotaging. Looking closer, they seem natural fallouts of the easily activated, challenging to suppress, interfering monetary thoughts that shape valuations and associations. Scarcity or the feeling of having less than one needs alters the decision-making process in itself. This sensitivity to 'what matters' changes preferences. Poverty triggered mechanisms make economic decisions more difficult by curtailing cognitive control.
The involuntary load presses the processing into redirecting the slower, deliberative system two towards what needs to be taken care of immediately. At the same time, other preferences get overwhelmingly guided by the faster, affective system—such recalibration in preference construction results in the rational-bias split or tunnelling. Our work is an inquiry into this dichotomy of risk preferences. We use the two-period natural harvest cycle combined with the priming of financial worries to study the decision-attribute dependent probability weighting of farmers in 800 people sample from Bwikhonge in Uganda for gains and losses in a between-within subject design. We explain the process that begins involuntarily with scarcity, has psychological implications and bifurcates the probability weighting function. For choices that resolve the scarcity at hand,  we find more expected utility consistent decisions. The probability weighting function is a straight line. In contrast, it is more curved for biased irrelevant choices.

Intervention

The design has three core elements - scarcity treatment, a cognitive load test and the risk-choice game. The experiment begins with identifying the sources of scarcity, measuring its impact on the cognitive systems and the probability weighting function for both gains and losses.

Experimental design

After allocation to gains or losses in both the natural periods, we randomly assign the scarcity priming treatment to half of the participants. This is followed up with a cognitive load test and a within-subject decision attribute treatment.

Design details

Randomization method
Coupon system
Randomization unit
Individual level randomisation for domain and scarcity treatment.
Clusters
Individual-level clustering at experiment nodes. Total participants across the two periods = 400+400.
Observations
Same as cluster
Arms
In all, we have the following treatments - domain (gains, losses), scarcity (natural, primed) and decision attribute (relevant, irrelevant). The first two are assigned between subjects, while the latter is within. Therefore, once the domain and scarcity treatment level is fixed, all participants face the second treatment. Sample size by treatment arms - Period 1 (Natural scarcity) = 400 Gains + Losses = 200 +200 Gains in period 1 = 200 Break up of 200 participant sample in the gains domain in period 1 - full treatment = (natural x primed x decision attribute) = 100 natural x non-primed x decision attribute treatment = 100 Losses in period 1 = 200 Break up of 200 participant sample in the losses domain in period 1 - full treatment = (natural x primed x decision attribute) = 100 natural x non-primed x decision attribute treatment = 100 Period 2 (No natural scarcity) = 400 Gains + Losses = 200 +200 Gains in period 2 = 200 Break up of 200 participant sample in the gains domain in period 2 - no natural scarcity x primed x decision attribute = 100 no natural scarcity x non-primed x decision attribute treatment = 100 Losses in period 2 = 200 Break up of 200 participant sample in the losses domain in period 2 - no natural scarcity x primed x decision attribute = 100 no natural scarcity x non-primed x decision attribute treatment = 100
Primary outcomes
We compare the differences in choice switches in the matched groups for each pair of rungs in each domain. There are three possibilities between the two attributes - -1, 0,1, and we intend to compare the number of total switches between scarcity relevant and irrelevant decisions for each probability ladder.
Secondary outcomes
1. Effectiveness of priming - the self-reported impact of shock scarcity. 2. Cognitive load test score - time and accuracy score on a two-question task. 3. Tracking the probability weighting function for each decision attribute, given the participants' scarcity state.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords