Refreshing iv cannulation skills using mental imagery in medical students: Rater-blinded three-arm intervention

How to cite

Berger, Joana. 2021. "Refreshing iv cannulation skills using mental imagery in medical students: Rater-blinded three-arm intervention." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008043. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8043-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Joana Berger*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008043
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8043-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2021-01-01 – 2021-10-31
Countries
Switzerland (Bern), Switzerland (Bern)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8043

Abstract

Background and Goal of Study:
Mental imagery has long been used to successfully improve top athletes’ performance during e.g. the Olympics. More recently, this educational strategy has also been used to learn surgical skills. Only a few studies describe the use of mental imagery in anesthesia and in undergraduate medical education. This study investigates the effectiveness of mental imagery compared to written instructions respectively to hands-on training in part-task trainers in maintaining the skills of intravenous cannulation on a part task trainer in first-year medical students.

Materials and Methods: We performed a single-center, rater-blinded randomized controlled trial. Students attended a compulsory 4h- instructor-led intravenous cannulation course six month before the trial. After ethics committee waiver but with written informed consent, first-year medical students were randomly assigned to one of three different six-minutes tutorials on intravenous cannulation six months after the i.v. cannulation course. Each group consisted either of self-learning tutorial based on written instructions, a hands-on iv cannulation tutorial on a manikin, or a tutorial with a mental imagery audioguide session.
The student´s performance was assessed with the use of a 15-item standardized checklist in a six-minute Objective Structured Clinical Examination station for intravenous cannulation. Assuming an alpha error of 0.01, and an effect size of a Cohen’s f of 0.305 with an aimed power of 0.80, our sample size resulted in a minimum of 156 students. We performed descriptive analysis of the data and a one-way ANOVA. An a priori probability of less than 0,05 was considered to be statistically significant. All data were analysed using SPSS v.27.

Results and Discussion: In the 309 students participating, we did not find differences in the performance between the three groups and the pass mark for the OSCE station. The internal consistency of station items was 0.691. The mental imagery group was as successful as both other groups. With the same outcome, mental imagery and written instruction have the better effort-return ratio compared to resource intensive hands-on training in part-task trainers.

Conclusion: Simple and short interventions with mental imagery and written instructions have been shown equal effective as hands-on exercises for refreshing a simple but important procedural skill in medical students.

Experimental design

Study Design:
We carried out a three-armed, rater-blinded randomized trial. Six months after their initial standard IV cannulation teaching, medical students were randomly assigned to 3 groups, using a block randomization software (www.sealedenvelope.com):
1) Group A: 8 min. standard refresher (kinesthetic group, with Part-task trainer only): Students had an allotted time to practice in the model, similarly to what had occurred in the course sessions. A supervising tutor was present in the room and offered concurrent feedback. All materials used during the course sessions were available.
2) Group B: 8 min. self-learning tutorial. Students randomized to this intervention practiced the IV cannulation technique alone, with the aid of a laminated instruction sheet (Appendix 1). Students in this group had all materials used during the course session at their disposal.
3) Group C: 8 min. Tutorial with guided Mental Imagery rehearsal of the competence (audio-guide only). Students listened to a Mental Imagery audio script of the procedure while lying down on a lounger. No iv cannulation materials are available.

Design details

Randomization method
medical students were randomly assigned to 3 groups, using a block randomization software (www.sealedenvelope.com)
Randomization unit
Block randomisation of 9 individuals
Clusters
Sample size calculation: The required sample size was calculated using an a priori power analysis with G*Power V.3.1.16 Assuming an effect size (f2=0.305) for a one way analysis of variance with three groups (α=0.01, 1-β=0.80), we found that the minimum required sample size for three groups was n=156. To compensate for 20% of non-responders, we aimed for 180 participants.
Observations
300 students
Arms
we found that the minimum required sample size for three groups was n=156 (52 for Standard Refresher; 52 Mental Imagery Intervention; 52 Control group)
Primary outcomes
OSCE 1st Year Assessment Marking for the IV cannulation station
Secondary outcomes
previous experience in healthcare, relatives working in the healthcare system, number of previous attempts in IV cannulation

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords