Frictions in Mortgage Refinancing
How to cite
Undurraga, Raimundo; Bhattacharya, Vivek; Cuesta, Jose Ignacio; Illanes, Gaston; Montoya, Ana Maria. 2021. "Frictions in Mortgage Refinancing." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007990. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7990-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Mortgage rates have decreased considerably in Chile over the past decade, but mortgage holders rarely refinance their loans. The Chilean National Consumer Service (SERNAC) is the agency of the State of Chile in charge of ensuring the protection of the rights of consumers. SERNAC has been considering using informational treatments to encourage consumers to refinance. However, the type of informational treatment that would be most effective would depend on the nature of the friction preventing consumers from refinancing. First, search may be costly: it may take substantial effort for a consumer to go from bank to bank soliciting offers. Second, switching may be costly: not only might it take mental effort to even start the process of searching for a loan (perhaps because the consumer is unaware even how to) but changing banks from one's home bank could require substantial effort. Third, consumers may have incorrect beliefs over the benefits of refinancing: they may be unaware of the prevailing interest rate in the market, for instance. Broadly, this project asks whether informational treatments can increase the prevalence of refinancing, and if so, what the behavioral frictions are that led to the low likelihood of refinancing.
To answer this question, we partner with a major national bank in Chile. We conduct three pieces of analysis. First, we conduct a survey of bank clients to solicit information about clients' understanding of the refinancing process, how they evaluate loans, and their beliefs over market rates. Second, we conduct a field experiment in which we distribute information about their current loan, the refinancing process, and the market rates to all mortgage holders with the Bank. This consists of approximately 250,000 clients. We randomize the clients into five treatment arms, each giving information about a different part of the process. Finally, we analyze the behavior post-treatment through the lens of a structural model to quantify the behavioral frictions.
Intervention
We randomize the population into a control or one of five information treatments. The population will receive an email from the Bank with a PDF file attached.
Control Group. A group of people will not get any additional letter through this experiment. They will however receive a standard letter describing the terms of their contract, although at a time pre-set by regulation and independent of the experiment. (All Chileans with mortgages receive this letter.)
Treatment to Change Beliefs of the Possibility of Refinancing. This letter will contain information about the recipient's current mortgage, a statement that alerts the recipient that it is possible to refinance one's mortgage and reduce the monthly payment (and defining what refinancing means), and a link where the recipient could find more information about the terms one can receive. It is on a regular-sized sheet and contains both the logo and the stamp of SERNAC.
Treatment to Alter Beliefs. This treatment arm provides information that alters the bias in the beliefs individuals have about the rates they will obtain in the market. Here, we include the information in the T1 treatment and also add graphical illustrations of where the individual stands in the distribution of prevailing interest rates. This documents (1) a short explanation that different financial institutions will offer different interest rates, (2) an interest rate ``thermometer'' that includes the mortgage holder's current interests and the average prevailing interest rates of refinanced loans that have similar characteristics, and (3) a written explanation of the information in the interest rate thermometer together with a computation that includes annual and total savings for a reduction in the interest rate to the market average. For those who are above the market rate, we show no savings (i.e., we do not show negative savings).
The prevailing market rates are computed using predicted values of a regression of interest rate on various characteristics. In particular, we run a regression of interest rate at the mortgage level on variables like loan amount, term, income, neighborhood (``comuna''), loan type, and whether the loan was a subsidy. Continuous variables are typically binned, and categorical variables are included as separate fixed effects. We then predict the rate using the borrower's current personal and mortgage characteristics, using the month FE for May 2021. The market average will be presented as what a customer would have received on average had they refinanced recently (with fine print outlining the idea behind the procedure).
Treatment to Alter Search Costs. This treatment arm is designed to facilitate search across banks. Since search could be difficult because either (i) customers are unable to compare contracts or because (ii) customers do not even know the process to search, we design a treatment that affects both avenues. First, the letter for this treatment includes the baseline information from above. Second, we include a diagram designed by SERNAC that aims to teach people how to compare different credit offers. Finally, we include a step-by-step checklist for how someone can solicit offers from different banks.
Treatment to Alter Switching Costs. In this treatment arm, we inform the recipient of the Portability Law, which makes it easier to port information between banks. We include the baseline information included in the control and then add a step-by-step checklist for how to change banks.
Full Treatment. This treatment arm includes all information from the previous treatments, aggregated together.
Experimental design
Experimental Sample. Our experimental sample consists of 254,515 bank clients with active mortgages by May 31, 2021. Of them, 247,311 were not surveyed at baseline (``Non-surveyed Sample (NS)"), while 7,204 were surveyed (``Surveyed Sample (S)").
Stratified Randomization: By June 26, 2021, we conducted a stratified-randomization considering the following set of dummies as stratification variables: gender (1 if the client is female); education (1 if the client has higher education degree); age (1 if the client is below the median age); degree of banking competition (1 if the client resides in a municipality (comuna) where the number of bank branches is below the median number of bank branches across municipalities); 5 quantile dummies of predicted savings (calculated based on the difference between the mortgage holder’s current interests and the average prevailing interest rates of refinanced loans that have similar characteristics) plus a zero predicted savings dummy (1 if predicted savings equals zero); and client's performance (1 if the client is cataloged by the bank as a ``good payer"). We form a total of 192 strata. Then, within each stratum, we randomly assigned each non-surveyed client to the control or one of the 5 treatment groups, with the number of observations per group almost evenly distributed across groups (around 41,220 observations per group). Likewise, within each stratum we randomly assigned surveyed clients to either the control or the ``Full Treatment" group (3,601 and 3,603 observations, respectively).
Implementation. The cartillas are officially delivered on July 21, 2021. A pilot round with 3,000 cases was implemented a week before (week of July 12, 2021). The objective of pilot round was to test whether the technological aspects of the experiments were functioning well (e.g., email system sent out by clients, etc.) and to bring forward potential concerns on the part of receiving clients. No changes were made to the design after the pilot was initiated.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.