Expanding Opportunity: Testing asset grants and jobs programs for Egypt’s poor

How to cite

Kurdi, Sikandra; Gilligan, Daniel; Palloni, Giordano; Yassa, Basma. 2021. "Expanding Opportunity: Testing asset grants and jobs programs for Egypt’s poor." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007944. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7944-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sikandra Kurdi* , Daniel Gilligan , Giordano Palloni , Basma Yassa

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007944
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7944-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2021-08-01 – 2024-06-01
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7944

Abstract

FORSA is a new program of the Egyptian government implemented by the Ministry of Social Solidarity which aims to graduate beneficiaries of the national cash transfer program "Takaful" to self-reliance. The program has two modalities: (1) an asset-transfer modality which is inspired by the BRAC graduation model approach and (2) a wage employment modality which focuses on job matching and training. Both modalities also include a behavioral change seminar intended to increase self-efficacy, financial literacy training, and ongoing mentoring provided by volunteers. A pilot funded by the World Bank is planned in 165 communities including 50,000 participants.
We will conduct a cluster randomized control trial of this pilot program to measure the impact and cost-effectiveness of the two approaches at raising wage and self-employment income and increasing consumption for participants and explore heterogenous effects by poverty level, match between actual and desired modality, and other baseline characteristics. The program activities are expected to last 12-18 months, from late 2021 to early 2023. We plan to collect baseline data in August 2021 prior to the intervention and follow-up data in August 2023. Because there is expected to be a high degree of self-selection into the program and into the separate modalities, our household sample will be based on a model of predicted participation conditional on administrative data on Takaful beneficiaries. This model will be trained using a separate sample of households for which uptake information is available prior to the baseline.
Our evaluation will complement a rich existing literature by exploring how the graduation model works when targeted to beneficiaries at various levels of poverty and when implemented at scale by a government. The asset-transfer modality will provide an example of an at-scale graduation program which provides an asset-transfer, training, savings group, and health messaging, but instead of investing in staff for weekly mentoring, will provide messaging and guidance through existing government structures. The wage employment modality will be primarily a job matching service with subsidized on-the-job training. A unique feature of the Forsa intervention is that it will also work with employers to improve job quality and work environments, responding to high turnover among workers.

Intervention

FORSA is a program initiated by the Ministry of Social Solidarity building on Takaful and Karama that aims to graduate beneficiaries from reliance on Takaful and Karama (TKP) cash transfers by supporting the economic inclusion and empowerment of TKP beneficiaries and rejected applicants just above the PMT threshold. Forsa’s main objective is to reduce longer term dependency on Takaful transfers by linking beneficiaries to employment services, the provision of training, and asset transfers. The Forsa graduation program includes two modalities: (1) an asset-transfer modality and (2) a wage employment modality which focuses on job matching and training. 70 percent of the Forsa budget will be allocated to the self-employment modality activities in regions with limited formal labor market opportunities, while 30 percent will target wage employment modality activities in regions with more potential access to formal labor market opportunities.
The Forsa package, for both the wage and self-employment modalities, costs approximately US$1000 per beneficiary; these costs include the provision of assets to be transferred to beneficiaries, technical and financial trainings, wage subsidies, and administrative fees. The Forsa program activities are expected to last between 12-18 months, depending on the modality.
Geographical targeting:
The geographic targeting will focus on eight governorates in Upper Egypt and Lower Egypt: Fayoum, Beni Suef, Assiut, Sohag, Luxor, Menia, Sharkiya and Qalyoubia. 330 villages were identified as potential sites based on district and governorate level targeting criteria (poverty and economic opportunity) and having at least 500 current TKP beneficiaries in the village. 165 individual villages within these governorates have been selected as program sites.

Targeting based on administrative data on household characteristics:
Eligibility is limited to TKP beneficiary households and TKP registrant households that fall just above the poverty cut-off point (exact range of PMT scores to be determined), with 30% of beneficiaries and sample households drawn from the latter group.
Based on information from the TKP registration database, eligible households must:
• have at least one working age member (19-55 years old)
• have a household head and (if present) spouse without formal employment
• own 5 qerats or less of land that is used in agriculture
• not be receiving a transfer/asset from any other program
• own no more than 4 medium-sized livestock or 1 large animal
• have a house with no more than one floor
• not be receiving remittances from a member working out of the country

Self-selection and behavioral change “nudge”:
Within treatment communities, a door-to-door campaign for the eligible households will be organized by the implementing NGOs: Al-Koura and CARE Organization. Local MoSS and MoH social unit employees (“raedaat”) will be tasked individually invite eligible households to attend behavioral change sessions about the Forsa program in their community.
The main objectives of the behavioral change sessions are to introduce more details about the modalities offered by the Forsa program and to emphasize the benefits of financial independence and economic empowerment relative to financial reliance and aid dependency. The behavioral change sessions will be small (approximately 40 participants) and separate sessions will be offered by gender and age category. Additionally, attendees will be made aware that cash transfers will not be stopped upon registration for Forsa, they will be sustained for 6 months to allow a smooth transition into self-reliance. Program registration will be opened for the participants at the end of the session to express their decision about joining Forsa.

Profiling and final selection:
The roll-out of behavioral change sessions will take several months and will be followed by a period of profiling. Households that registered their interest at the behavioral change session will be interviewed to gather information about their work experience and preferences and based on this profile, 50,000 individuals will be selected by MoSS for inclusion in the Forsa program pilot.

Intervention services:
For the self-employment track: the service will be conducted by the contracted NGOs under the supervision of MoSS program staff. During the session, the NGOs staff will present to the beneficiaries the list of assets that could be transferred and the general and asset-specific trainings that will be offered such as financial literacy training, business development and entrepreneurship skills training, asset-specific/technical training and regular coaching. The asset costs and the associated trainings are valued at US$1000 per beneficiary.
FORSA participants will be given the option to either choose the asset on the spot, or to submit their choice after 2 to 3 days after discussing the options with other household members. In some cases, another physical verification visit may be prearranged to assess the suitability of the household for asset keeping and considering environmental factors.
Beneficiaries will also benefit from an ongoing mentoring relationship with a volunteer participating in a national service program.
For the wage employment track: the service will be conducted at the village level, through a Training and an Employment unit at affiliated premises to MoSS, or/and through collaborations with other partners when needed, such as the Job Search Clubs, established by the ILO in collaboration with Ministry of Youth, where sessions can take place to inform beneficiaries about the package components/services offered in the wage-employment modality and the expected timeline for delivering these components. The wage employment modality offers several components/services that fall under two main categories: 1) availing employment opportunities for unskilled, semi-Skilled and skilled labor in the formal private sector; 2) creation of new jobs categories such as assistant nurse, elderly care, home cleaning and babysitting services.
The wage employment package includes technical and soft skills trainings for employment; a benefit package offered in collaboration with the employer through which MoSS finances wage subsidies for up to six months (to be determined), health insurance, social security coverage, annual and sick leave, and life insurance; and a job-matching and mentoring program which is considerably more involved than a one-time support for the beneficiaries as it includes resolving issues and potentially finding a new match if the beneficiary loses or wants to leave their employment during the program period.

Experimental design

The study relies on a cluster randomized controlled trial to estimate the causal impacts of the offer of access to the Forsa program on outcomes, with two rounds of data collection. A baseline household survey will collect information on outcomes, and key characteristics expected to be predictive of future outcomes prior to the start of the Forsa program. An endline survey will re-survey the same households two years later to measure outcomes and characteristics that enable tests of different potential mechanisms in the causal chain.
The sample will include 7,920 households, 3,960 each from treatment and control villages with 24 households sampled per village.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization will take place at the sub-village level, stratified at the district level and by the size of the population eligible to participate in the Forsa program, using randtreat Stata package, with a seed of 1142021 and using the wglobal option for misfits. 165 villages were allocated to the treatment arm and another 165 villages were allocated to the control arm.
Randomization unit
sub-village
Clusters
330
Observations
7,920
Arms
165 subvillages control (3,960 hhs) 165 subvillage treatment (3,960 hhs)
Primary outcomes
Both modalities: 1. Total Household Consumption Employment modality only: 1. Unemployment rate including all household members ages 15-64 2. Underemployment rate for all household members ages 15-64 Asset transfer modality only: 1. Continued ownership of transferred assets 2. Weekly time spent by targeted member in productive activities
Secondary outcomes
Secondary Outcomes (endpoint): Both modalities: 1. Total Household Food Consumption by broad category 2. Total Household Non-Food Consumption by broad category 3. Implied Consumption Share for Children, Men, and Women 4. Net Debt and Savings including informal saving and borrowing methods such as gamaiya and installment plans 5. Self-Efficacy of Targeted Member 6. Women’s Decision-Making 7. Subjective measure of life satisfaction 8. Financial literacy 9. Financial inclusion Employment modality only: 1. Targeted member works in formal sector 2. Targeted member current wage 3. Targeted member monthly income variance over past 6 months 4. Targeted member has work certification 5. Targeted member valuation of formality of employment Asset transfer modality only: 6. Total weekly time spent by all household members over age 5 in productive activities 7. Total weekly time spent by all household members over age 5 on child and elder care We will explore heterogeneity of program impact on the following household and individual characteristics that we believe are likely to influence ability to benefit from the intervention. In each case, we will test for heterogeneity by interacting the treatment dummy with a demeaned baseline value of the characteristic. 1. PMT score 2. Risk aversion 3. Uncertainty aversion 4. Score based on self-reported literacy and numeracy 5. Digit span and reverse digit span scores 6. Stated preference at baseline between self-employment and wage-employment (possibly also interacting with rural and urban if these are strong predictors of wage-employment or self-employment modality being offered in a community)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords