Evaluation of Demand-led Vocational Training Programs in Pakistan
How to cite
Montenbruck, Laura; Stelter, Matthias; Avdeenko, Alexandra. 2021. "Evaluation of Demand-led Vocational Training Programs in Pakistan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007910. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7910-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The traditional TVET (Technical and Vocational Education and Training) sector in Pakistan has a variety of different training programs. However, many graduates do not find long-term employment. One major reason for this seems to be an imbalance between the jobs and skills in demand on the labor market and the programs offered by the training institutions. Within this study, we evaluate the effectiveness of a demand-led TVET program in Badin and Kashmore in adapting learners’ employment expectations and increasing the likelihood of long-term employment. The program was designed based on a market needs assessment and as such answers the need of more market-oriented training programs. This makes it a promising alternative to traditional programs, which is likely to generate better employment outcomes at a similar cost.
Intervention
The intervention is implemented at the individual level. Individuals are randomly chosen for one of six training sectors: advanced mobile repairing and software, beautician, computerized accounting, electrician and plumber, mobile repairing, or tailoring. The respective sectors have been selected based on a market needs assessment prior to the intervention’s start.
Individuals in the treatment group participate in a pre-internship and, unless they disqualify due to low attendance rates, continue to the training phase afterwards.
We will collect post-intervention data via a phone follow up survey and hence expect some attrition. This will be illustrated and handled appropriately.
Experimental design
We conduct a pilot RCT with a single intervention, a combined internship and training program to improve the integration of youths into the labor market. To do so, 210 youths are randomly selected for treatment, whereas 100 youths serve as the control group. Both the treatment and the control group are selected from a pool of eligible individuals who stated their interest to participate in a TVET training and fulfil a set of eligibility criteria defined by the implementing NGO, ACTED Pakistan. They have been interviewed and were equally eligible to continue with the TVET training. The randomization is carried out in several steps: Following a set of interviews for a specific trait, ACTED shared a list of eligible candidates and a randomization into treatment and control group (with varying shares per trait) was carried out. In total, eight such batches of groups for randomization exist.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.