Welfare, Work, and Wellbeing: Evidence from an Informal Settlement in Kenya
How to cite
Bhanot, Syon; Han, Jiyoung; Jang, Chaning. 2015. "Welfare, Work, and Wellbeing: Evidence from an Informal Settlement in Kenya." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000788. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.788-5.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Governments have long relied on cash transfers and vouchers as key elements of social welfare systems. Consumer theory offers predictions about the impact of such programs on wellbeing and spending behavior, but there is little real-world evidence. In this paper, we outline the pre-analysis plan for a randomized field experiment to explore the effect of welfare program design on these two key outcomes. We specifically test three design features: 1) workfare versus welfare; 2) restricted versus unrestricted vouchers; and 3) voucher messaging with a focus on spending on oneself or on others. The ten-day experiment involved 432 individuals living below the poverty line in the Kawangware settlement of Nairobi, Kenya. Each day, subjects either sorted lentils or waited in a room for benefit payments, provided as vouchers to a local grocery store. We either restricted the vouchers to certain basic food items or did not restrict them, and we also randomized voucher messaging. We outline the analysis plan of the impact of these experimental treatments on happiness, productivity, and consumption decisions.
Experimental design
Subjects
The subjects in this experiment were 432 individuals living in the Kawangware area of Nairobi, Kenya, selected at random for recruitment to the study from the subject pool maintained by the Busara Center for Behavioral Economics.
Study Design
The field experiment was conducted in Kawangware, an informal settlement located approximately 15 kilometers from the Nairobi city center. Participants were randomly assigned to three treatment groups, described below, located in three different community halls. Each community hall hosted four sessions per day at the same times each day: 9:30 AM, 11:30 AM, 1:30 PM, and 3:30 PM.
After subjects were recruited by phone, they were asked to select one of four time slots during the day for their participation in the study. Once participants were confirmed for a given time slot, they were randomly assigned to one of the three treatment groups and notified of the location where they had to report every day. The assignment to one of three treatment groups were not known to the participants prior to arrival at the location. This design helped avoid any selection bias stemming the time of day that people chose for their participation in the study.
Treatment Groups
Subjects were randomized into three main treatment groups, namely:
1. Work: People who worked in the treatment location for one hour each day in exchange for a daily payment of two unconditional PBK Nonic Supermarket vouchers.
2. Wait – Unconditional: People who waited in the treatment location for one hour each day in exchange for a daily payment of two unconditional PBK Nonic Supermarket vouchers.
3. Wait – Hybrid: People who waited in the treatment location for one hour each day in exchange for a daily payment of one unconditional PBK Nonic Supermarket voucher and one conditional PBK Nonic Supermarket voucher that could be used for “basic” food items only (Maize/wheat flour, rice, sugar, or cooking oil).
The total face value of the vouchers provided each day to the subjects was therefore across treatments, and was an amount slightly higher than an average daily wage for most participants.
Design details
Papers from this trial
- Bhanot, S.P., J. Han and C. Jang. 2018. Workfare, Wellbeing and Consumption: Evidence from a Field Experiment with Kenya’s Urban Poor. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 149, 372-388. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jebo.2018.01.007
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.