How Voting Rules Impact Legitimacy
How to cite
Hausladen, Carina Ines; Pournaras, Evangelos; Helbing, Dirk; Kunz, Renato; Hänggli, Regula; Wang, Junling. 2021. "How Voting Rules Impact Legitimacy." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007871. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7871-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Collective action is essential for addressing the grand challenges of our time. However, for such action to be successful, decision-making processes must be perceived as legitimate. In this study, we investigate the legitimacy of different voting methods.
Using a pre-registered human subject experiment, 120 participants cast their votes using four voting methods: majority voting, combined approval voting, score voting and modified Borda count. These methods represent a range of preference elicitation designs, from low to high complexity and flexibility.
Furthermore, we developed a legitimacy scale upon which the participants rate the voting methods.
The experiment was conducted in a non-political setting (voting on colour preferences) and a political context (voting on COVID-19-related questions).
Our findings suggest that the perceived legitimacy of a voting method is context-dependent. Specifically, preferential voting methods are considered more legitimate than majority voting in political decision-making, but only for individuals with well-defined preferences.
Furthermore, preferential voting methods are more legitimate than majority voting in a highly polarized situation.
Intervention
The intervention follows a between-subjects design: Participants provide legitimacy ratings at three different stages of the experiment. The ratings vary w.r.t. context and whether they were provided after voting or examining outcomes of the vote.
Experimental design
The experiment has three main stages. At each stage, participants provide legitimacy ratings, varying the context and action preceding the rating.
In stage I, participants vote upon a trivial, non-critical context (their favourite colour). Subsequently, they provide legitimacy ratings.
In stage II, participants vote upon a complex, critical context (COVID-19). Subsequently, they provide legitimacy ratings.
Finally, in stage III, participants observe the outcome of the vote and subsequently provide legitimacy ratings.
Design details
Materials
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.