A foundational result in behavioral economics is that decision-makers treat losses differently than gains. Until now, this difference has largely been hypothesized to be driven by an underlying “loss aversion” value function (Kahneman and Tversky, 1979). We hypothesize that losses may also focus decision-makers more effectively than gains, causing them to expend more cognitive effort.
Experimental design
We examine how financial incentives affect cognitive effort and outcomes.
Design details
Randomization method
By Qualtrics
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
600 Individuals
Observations
600 Individuals
Arms
200 per arm
Primary outcomes
Primary Outcomes:
• Time spent deliberating:
o Qualtrics quietly keeps track of how long participants spend on each of the seven CRT questions and the total amount of time spent on the entire survey. Our first primary outcome is the total time spent on the seven questions.
o We may also control for the total time spent on the entire survey.
o We will winsorize the time spent data if it is sufficiently noisy (e.g., some people may just click through, and others might get distracted or walk away from their computer briefly).
• Number of correct versus intuitive choices:
o We will count the number of correct responses.
o We will also count the number of intuitively wrong CRT answers a participant submits as a measure of system I versus system II usage.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary Outcomes:
• NASA responses:
o Responses to the five NASA cognitive load/effort questions are recorded on a scale between 0 and 10, which we will treat cardinally.
o We will focus on responses to the prompts, “How mentally demanding were these questions?”
o “How hard did you have to work to accomplish your level of performance?”
o “How much attention were you paying to the questions as you answered them?”
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.