Joint Accounts in the Fintech Era: How Does Labelling, Transparency and, Approval Rules Affect Spousal Financial Decision Making?
How to cite
Jose, Anu; King, Michael; Bedi, Tara. 2021. "Joint Accounts in the Fintech Era: How Does Labelling, Transparency and, Approval Rules Affect Spousal Financial Decision Making?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007833. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7833-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study revisits the topic of joint accounts and assess how their terms, increasingly varied due to innovations in the fintech sector, affect intrahousehold allocation decisions. Through an experimental lab setting in Kolkata, India, we assess the impact of labeling, transparency and spousal approval on expenditure allocations of spouses. We also assess the impact of personally earning money on subsequent expenditure decisions of couples and specifically under different joint account terms. This study contributes to the literature in three ways. First, we contribute to existing experimental literature on joint accounts, extending it in the context of the fintech era. Second, we contribute to the literature on the impacts of financial product access/individualization on welfare-enhancing allocation decisions. Third, we contribute to the social protection literature on the relevance of workfare versus transfers. Specifically, we build on the behavioral economics concept of mental accounting, where Thaler (2008) suggested that earned money may be treated differently to unearned money.
Intervention
This study revisits the topic of joint accounts and assess how their terms, increasingly varied due to innovations in the fintech sector, affect intrahousehold allocation decisions. Through an experimental lab setting in Kolkata, India, we assess the impact of labeling, transparency and spousal approval on expenditure allocations of spouses. We also assess the impact of personally earning money on subsequent expenditure decisions of couples and specifically under different joint account terms.
This study uses random assignment to establish a causal relationship between different types of intervention and outcomes. There are two randomization levels: one, based on a work requirement of female partners, and second, based on various joint account terms such as privacy, labeling, and communication. The first level of randomization determines whether the female partner would work during the first half an hour. The second level of randomization determines differential levels of information, labeling, and communication among couples concerning their financial decisions.
Under the different types of treatment at the first and second randomization levels, couples make decisions on how they wish to allocate a certain amount of money into six different options such as: depositing in their own bank account, depositing in their partners’ bank account. depositing to a third persons’ bank account, a personal gift voucher to buy female clothing, footwear and other accessories, a personal gift voucher to buy male clothing, footwear and other accessories, and a shared gift voucher to buy household items. Participants are also asked how they plan to spend the amount towards different types of expenditure which ranges from savings to children’s expenditure to different types of daily expenditure goods such as food items and personal goods. We will also capture information on for whom participants would like to spend the amount on, for example, for self or partner or children or other family, non-family members.
Experimental design
Participants in this study are 1,000 couples who live in semi-urban Kolkata, India selected at random from the client pool maintained by several microfinance organizations and NGOs based in Kolkata. Participants are initially contacted via phone and asked if they are willing to participate in the study.
In order to be eligible for the study, couples have to meet the following criteria:
1. The household head is married and his/her spouse lives within the household.
2. Both the head and spouse are literate in local language.
3. Both the head and spouse have individual bank accounts.
4. Both the head and spouse are 60 or less years of age.
This study uses random assignment to establish a causal relationship between different types of intervention and outcomes. One thousand couples are selected based on the eligibility criteria determined by their age, literacy, relationship status and having an individual bank account each. There are two randomization levels: one, based on a work requirement of female partners, and second, based on various joint account terms such as privacy, labeling, and communication. The first level of randomization determines whether the female partner would work during the first half an hour. The second level of randomization determines differential levels of information, labeling, and communication among couples concerning their financial decisions. Two hundred couples will be in each treatment arm which has restrictions on information, labeling, and communication to complete an allocation game, with half coming from the ‘task’ stream and half from the ‘gift’ stream.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.